Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
MEIO BOM E MEIO RUIM
Vamos por partes.Do começo até a metade essa série é simplesmente perfeita, juro, não tenho nenhuma reclamação. É engraçada, fofa, os casais coadjuvantes são interessantes e o ritmo é bem fluido.
O problema vem quando vai chegando no final.
Da metade pra frente a história decai muito com o casal principal, são problemas o tempo todo e emenda em uma separação de anos (sempre vou enfatizar o quanto eu odeio passagem de tempo, eu acho a coisa mais terrível do mundo e perde o encanto pra mim), e o pior, a separação foi causada porque um queria "salvar o dia" e fez isso de propósito deixando o outro pensar que ele não o amava.
Fiquei triste em ver toda uma construção leve e bonita ser jogada no lixo e ser restaurada apenas no finalzinho. Os casais secundários salvaram a experiência desse final sofrido.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Não é qualquer roteiro que desenvolve 4 casais de forma decente
De imediato, vi apenas uma história clichê universitária, onde o malvadão se apaixona pelo mocinho super inteligente, mas essa série me deu uma boa lição sobre não julgar o livro pela capa.Inicialmente, o casal principal são como água e vinho. Numa reviravolta sem lógica alguma eles são escalados para promoverem a universidade como um casal imaginário BL, e até conseguem fazer isso, mas em meio a admiradores de Kimhan, a personalidade difícil e sem noção de Mek, a falta de diálogo entre eles, a história de amor desanda e só volta a acontecer no fim da série, que se passa depois de um salto temporal, quando os dois já estão formados e trabalhando.
Mek é totalmente sem noção e tem um canal no Youtube de pegadinhas super constrangedoras junto com seus dois amigos. Kimhan é o nerd que também tem seus dois amigos íntimos. Um belo plow twist se dá quando é revelado que um dos amigos de Mek já namora há 6 anos em segredo com um dos amigos de Kim, inclusive eles tem um relacionamento super saudável e eu não entendi inicialmente o motivo de ser escondido. O segundo amigo de Kim também se apaixona pelo segundo amigo de Mek e passam a viver uma linda história, enquanto os próprios Mek e Kim não conseguem se entender e colocam barreiras imaginárias entre si. Na verdade, eles só confessam seus sentimentos na primeira vez graças às suas irmãs que armam pra eles ficarem sozinhos, mas nem isso é suficiente para manter os dois juntos, pois quando Kim descobre que o sonho de Mek é estudar em outro país, toma sozinho a decisão de se separar para evitar que ele desista do seu sonho (Tailândia e seus dramas complicados que facilmente se resolveriam com 5 minutos de conversa).
Enquanto isso, o admirador de Kim, Tim, corre atrás dele, sem perceber que seu verdadeiro amor é seu melhor amigo Mai, e só se dá conta disso quando Mai decide viver a vida e sair com outros.
Percebam que existem 4 casais. A grandiosidade dessa série está nesse detalhe: ela conseguiu desenvolver todos os casais de forma coerente e produtiva, bem desenvolvida e dando um final lindo a cada um deles.
Fora isso, não existem muitos furos. A atuação é boa (que maravilha ver Earth de volta, e como protagonista), fotografia, ost, roteiro, tudo muito bom. Recomendo muito essa série.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
KelpiView : They are my secret love too.
Overall impression:Hmm. My initial impression of the show is just that. Honestly, when it first started, it wasn't really on my weekly list at all. Though at this point, i do not know when i became so invested in it. The show itself starts slow, that i must say. getting past that slow start, is all it takes to make me into a obsessed fan and I truly appreciate the production crew in producing this gem of a show.
What I liked about it:
Great cast!
A good story meets a great cast, that is what i think My Secret Love is. Despite some of the cast member not having any experience under their belt like Bew (Park) and Por (Bear), as well as Kenji (Mai) and boat (Tim). They did exceedingly well portraying their characters. The leads are not very lovable at the start, that i must say. But the more i watch each week, the more that i like them for their character portrayals. However the supporting couples of this show totally stole my heart. all 3 of them lol.
Evolving Genre!
I initially thought this show could be tagged as a comedy due to the amount of laugh i had for the start of the show. As i mention, it started slow, but the only reason i continued watching it was because of the comedic elements that is present throughout the show. Tho, it was very comedy centric at the start which really helped in my opinion. As the story progresses, they showed glimpses of each couples backstory and trouble and that sets the mood for a concrete scenario in my opinion. The show should definitely be tagged as a rom com.
Awesome OST
As Im typing out this review, the ost from Jeff Satur (look) is playing in the background. That is how much i would love to give this song an honorary mention. It helps that its jeff satur. But the mood of the song itself fits well with the show that every time i hear the song, i would immediately associate it to the show.
What I disliked about it:
Slow Start.
No show is perfect in my opinion. as people we can never be satisfied fully. But that's really ok. One small detail that i wish could be done differently was the slow start, but that being said, its not a deal breaker for me as i enjoyed the comedy route that they begun with.
Inadequate ParkLee scenes.
Okay, this may be pushing it a little bit, BUT. hear. me. out. I just felt that there should be more ParkLee scenes in the show.... because.. just because.. i wanted more of them. lol. one of my favourite on screen secondary couple by far. their backstory was so cute. i wish they would make a story of park and lee in another series.
Did I enjoy it?:
I really enjoyed this one. as i mentioned, it started slow but really stuck on to me and i really enjoyed the ride.
Would I recommend it to others?:
Definitely. Though some people might be a lil bored of the university setting, but if you are ok with that and like a multiple couple show like me. and appreciate a good show, i think you should definitely give it a try! To me, a certain setting might not deter me to try a show because even though the setting is the same, its the cast that brings the character and story to life and that makes a whole lot of difference. So, if you have time and wanna be emotionally invested, give My Secret Love a try!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
a solid rom com
Overall: this was an enjoyable rom com and with a few changes I would have given it a 10/10. If Mek annoys you the first episode, please keep watching. Watched on YouTube.Content Warnings: non con video recording/posting, non con/dub con kisses (sleeping), blackmail, punch
What I Liked
- Mek's parents are adorable and the discussion of blended families and marriage equality line were absolutely amazing
- funny moments
- sweet and caring moments
- managed to balance four couples pretty well but I think if they had cut it to three it would have been even better
- an established couple
- some character growth with Mek but I did still get annoyed at him a few times in the final episodes
- the ending was lovely
- realistic and continuous physical affection (instead of 1 kiss at the very end)
- Jeff Satur's OST/singing
Room For Improvement
- the chancellor was stupid/not funny, I wish it had been the guys' idea like in the original pilot and they removed the chancellor character entirely
- the cliche drama point at the end with Mek/Kim
- Kim didn't grow as much as I had wished
- the sisters were involved a bit too much at the beginning but then they oddly vanished at the end
- unknown time passed in the time jumps
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
A lot of secrets, a lot of love... an lot of cringe...
This is a drama that made me wonder, is this a parody or are they for real?The acting ranges between really bed (intentionally?) and mediocre. The dialog is cringe, cringe and well more cringe... and the music is catchy, there is a lot of kissing but most of the kisses have less chemistry than a 1st grade math class and are puppy meets dead fish. So this is basically a pretty awful low quality drama in every way possible... other than some abs and gorgeous smiles... here and there... yet I found this oddly addictive and entertaining...
There is just so much stupidity in this but it is not the annoying type of stupid so it kind of works. The PPL and K-drama references are present in every single episode making me wonder if this is a BL gone K-drama gone bad... Hate to Love possessive male lead changes when he meets organised mature male lead...
With jealousy, shippers and fall on your lips kisses... Not a healthy relationship in sight, and a whole lot of odd pacing... So I would say this is so bad it is mediocre but entertaining, worth a watch if you are in need to just let your brain go and just watch the cringe as it unfolds in front of you...
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
The Ratings Proves A Point
I love this. So many BLs are getting low ratings lately because they dont have the heated or face eating scenes as others, SL proves that it is unnecessary to have all the toxic behaviors, you can still enjoy getting caught up between multiple MLs stories without too much angst, The only thing I would change is to make Tim suffer a little bit more for his arrogance. If others come to bring down SL rating as they will because of their hidden agendas, just watch for yourself and make your own decisions, you will have no regrets with a smile on your face.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Tropes: jock/nerd, enemies to lovers, friends to lovers, reunion romance, secret romance, LTR
Y-novel adaptation originally slated as Secret Admirer (teaser) about an “ordinary guy still in love with the older boy he lived next door to during university,” starring Earth Teerapat (Wayo in 2 Moons 2) opposite Fluk (seasoned but not done BL). Plot entirely changed from novel to an absurdist: boys are forced by their university to be a BL couple for promo - although this conceit did give the show license to lampoon BL tropes (which I kinda enjoyed). But the show was VERY awkward with poor chemistry across the board.Lead couple had a tom/jerry vibe with the uke too stiff and serious and the seme a prankster immature idiot - one of my least favorite dynamics (it always seems mean-spirited). They reminded me of My Boy (which I DNFd) X BonDuen from My Engineer (who I dislike).
Other pairs include BearBomb, TimMai, and ParkLee (LTR whom use ter with each other - cute). The domesticity with the side couples was somewhat engaging, and the medium heat sex scenes were descent, but that’s it. The main couple is a little better after the time jump, mostly because Mek in now understandably arrogant. I guess.
I ended up fast forwarding everything that didn’t have the Tim storyline in it because I am a shallow shallow person. I also kept thinking that the actor playing Tim would’ve made a great Dr Pha in 2 Moons.
The worst thing about this show (aside from leads chemistry) was that the chemistry of the friendship groups felt off too. Normally, Thailand can handle friendship groups well. But these 2 different groups? I didn’t believe they were friends at all.
This drama suddenly got sensible and interesting in the finale after the time jump, and the reason for the split turned out to be a decent one. But frankly, that was just frustrating. Because I got a glimpse that this could’ve actually been, if not a GREAT show, at least a passable one. But they saved this for the last 2 eps? That’s just annoying. Another wedding makes me feel like this trope is becoming ubiquitous in Thai BL. Who knew Grey Rainbow would end up with us here?
In the end I can't really recommend this. There's much better Thai BL these days, and tons of it.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
surprisingly turned out to be the best thing ever
I can hardly express in words how much I loved this series. The first few episodes set a tone that ends up being much different from the rest of the show, but it gives a lot of key details and backstory that become important later. There were realistic, yet interesting twists, funny dialogue, well-timed inserts of the music and effects, and an overall consistency that some shows just lack.The characters are all so lovable. Even ones you may dislike at some point still grow on you by the end. Each couple brings something different to the plot, and I think that makes them all feel like key ingredients to the dynamic. I love how all characters were connected somehow, and it didn't feel like some of them were living on a different planet. Everyone was friends or at least close enough, and it makes you feel like you're watching a group of besties live out their lives.
The writing is by far this drama's strongest area, although it is really strong in every other aspect as well. The dialogue and details were so well done I found myself screaming at times.
I want to say it is simplistic, even though there's always a lot going on, but that is just the vibe here. Well done simplicity with some comedic elements and tasteful use of some classic tropes. 10/10, I really REALLY recommend this.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Kind of a guilty pleasure
This is not good. It's not terrible, but the writing is unimaginative and derivative. It's almost saved by its cast, but there is a glaring problem that prevented this from being the best execution of this plot type.The problem is the main couple, which is a pointless and cliched story that is poorly written throughout, which is unfortunate, because none of the side couples (and there are three of them) have this issue. Even then, it might have been saved if the actors were fanastic with electric chemistry. And Fluke as Mek has a certain charm. But Earth... his acting is wholy lacking in authenticity - everything he does looks fake, even blinking (how can blinking look fake you ask? I don't know. But Earth manages it). He's not assisted by the writing, which makes Kim a prissy, grumpy and unpleasant person, who has no character developmen at all. As opposed to Mek, who turns 180 degrees from who he was like a light switch being flipped - he goes from a charming carefree prankster into a featureless dullness which paired with Kim makes you resent the amount of time spend on them in the finale.
The side couples are some of the best you'll ever see. Lee and Park are rather unusual in the way they meet and get togther, which is refreshing and interesting, and allows the story to examine a much different set of issues. Acted by two beautiful and talented actors, Daniel Cheng (Marco from Call It What You Want) and Bew Sitthikarn, a newcomer who I hope we see a lot more of, this is a compelling couple.
Bear and Bomb are a high-contrast couple, played by the lovable Por Patsakon and the pouty-sexy Yut Kritsadayut, with great chemistry and complimentary personalities. Tim and Mai don't get much screentime, but they also become interesting later on as the brooding popular boy and the perfect man for him in his taken-for-granted best friend who's always at his side encouraging him.
This series is too full of tropes and cliches to give it a high score, but if it had dispensed with the main couple and focused on the other three pairs, perhaps with Lee & Park as the main, this could have been an 8.5 or 9. I'm not sure why this keeps happening - I think maybe it's because the main couple has a "gimmick" and ends up having its story constrained by it, while secondary couples have more freedom. Also, for reasons that I'm not sure I understand, rookie actors are cast as mains, relegating the experienced and talented actors to side roles.
Anyway, despite the above, I do recommend this series - it was a guilty pleasure for me, but for the side characters. The cast is unusually attractive and charming, and I did get a lot of pleasure from it even if I had to put Kim & Mek on 2x to get through their tiresome scenes.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Not overly impressed
Well I am sort of glad this drama has come to an end. it was neither good or bad, it was for me kind of immature and not what i was really expecting from it.The dialog was cringe, there was no chemistry between the leads, and for me that was really putting off, was a high school principal encouraging this kind of behavior instead of setting an example etc ... So this is basically a pretty awful low quality drama in every way possible, that was not leave very much to remember about.
The friendship groups were for me a complete disaster how on earth are friends with someone , and not realize that they have been in a relationship for over 7 years , and too keep that a secret for so long as well is really surprising for me too.
Overall: I can't really recommend this. There's much better Thai BL these days, and tons of it.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
A cute pleasant surprise
When I originally started this series, I was not expecting too much for it. I basically started watching this series to fill my Saturdays. However, as each week passed by, this series grew on me.This series had not one, not two, not three, but FOUR couples. And somehow they were able to give them enough screentime so that all four relationships can be developed. And that's a rarity. I'm still in shock that they still somehow manage to do this actually.
While I didn't like the beginning of the storyline for the main couple, it grew on me. Each week I was actually eager to watch this series to see what was going to happen next.
And yes, maybe this series has so much BL troupes in them, but hey! It somehow worked for this series.
I know that I am going to miss this series. If you want a cute, fluffy light BL series to watch- give this one a go. Don't pay to much attention to the rating, though. It does deserve a higher score than 7.6.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
It's one big cliché
The longer I'm thinking about this series, the lower score I want to give it. Each part of it is just... not good? And somehow out of blue? Not really forced, but you'll literally find out what's gonna happen the second it starts (4 seconds it lasts) and for the most part, *le sighs* will be the most authentic response. Don't expect to be surprised. Actually, don't expect anything. It's better that way.I'm going to skip all that information about couples, plotlines, symbols and whatnots. It wouldn't help you decide either way. Here, have some random tags instead : Enemies-to-lovers. Best friends-to-lovers. Inhaler. Plant abuse. Cooking. Hotel. Shipping. Fans. Kangaroo. OISHI (you wish). Shrimp paste. SOTUS. Zombies. Bears. Neighbours.
To say what I liked about this - product placements. They go ALL OUT! You wouldn't believe how many people use the same product seemingly independently of each other in this show.
To say what I didn't like about this - it was so wasteful as a story. It told nothing interesting, and whatever it told was shallow enough to be mixed with product placements at any given moment (so at least some plus to that "plot"). It watches okay-ish-ish-ish, but it won't bring you anything new. Nothing goes too deep, because any story arc has but a few minutes until another trope's lined up and fired.
Who would I recommend this for - You simp over one of the actors and have nothing better to spend your time on. You're just looking for something to vibe with while you're cooking dinner or doing chores. You're feeling catatonic and just need something to mess with you, a little bit.
Who would I not recommend this for - You're looking for something at least slightly unique. You prefer fewer, deeper plots compared to mutliple fractured ones. You value your time.
Overall, I'm just surprised this was even made. It's hard to find something so uninspired, yet utterly filled with (copied) ideas that go nowhere. It's like they tried to develop something, only to give up midway. Tried again. And again, not clearing up the previous attempts. I guess we're just rolling with it.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?