soapy melodrama that doesn't reinvent any wheels. if you like this genre, you'll like this drama.
TLDR: mixed feelings all around. It's soapy. It's cheesy. Nothing new. If you're going into it as a fan of this specific subgenre (military/medical patriotic drama w/melodrama romance), you'll be fine. It was too cheese and unrealistic for me.- The music is tonally heavy-handed, which I guess is expected for this genre (military/medical melodrama). The main OST for our CP: You Are My Everything - by Gummy is unbearably corny and overbearing. I hate it with a fiery passion. It cheapens every scene our CP is in and comes in loud and over the top every time. I like the song that plays between Dae Young and Myung Joo. It's uber pretty and reflects the yearning they feel for each other. That song is called "Once Again" - by Mad Clown & Kim Na Young.
- Chemistry between Shi-jin and Dae Young is more fun to watch than that between Shin Jin with Mo Yeon.
- I was invested in the relationship between Dae Young and Myung Joo from the very first moment. Talk about sizzling chemistry, yearning, and a n g s t.
- Foreign dramas constantly hiring non-American/poor English speaking actors to play "dumb Americans" always gives me the b i g g e s t eye roll. Beyond cringe. More cringe points for hiring awful F-list foreign actors for all of the American and Arab English-speaking parts. It's hard to watch; thank god for fast-forward.
- Despite the cringe English speaking portions and the Superhero music whenever Song Joon Ki blinks, I've been warming up to the drama more and more. Her dumping him (she had a valid reason that neither I nor Joon-Ki's character could fault her for) and the time skip helped greatly.
- Ep 6 note: Why TF would a doctor travel to a solar plant site collapse post-Earthquake in heels? Only to make a dramatic show of smacking those heels on a metal structure, so they fall off. D R A m A. *eye roll*
How many goodbyes and slow-walking away scenes will we need to watch? For the umpteenth time. Loses its effect.
-Ep 14: Hi, when you're shot MULTIPLE times and just suffered cardiac arrest, you're not strong enough to SIT UP and WALK moments later. Come on.
TLDR: People who like this genre will likely eat it up. I think I had higher hopes for it because of the high rating and because I'm a Song Joon Ki fan, but it was too sappy and unrealistic to appreciate. I liked the secondary couple storyline and the camaraderie between the soldiers more than the CP, by a long shot. There's nothing special about this drama; I feel my time could have been better spent elsewhere.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Well it was definitely not what I anticipated
Honestly saying I was excited to watch this drama,because I've heard so many people praising it previously, and I also liked the cast,but I got really disappointed. Basically the premise of the drama is that there's a soldier and a doctor who love each other, but I didn't think that will be all there is to see. But funnily Enough, I didn't enjoy the romance at all, the lead couple fell in love in the first episode without context and I just really wasn't into that, I didn't feel any connection between the 2 at all. But still, I think the worst thing about this drama was that the plot was that there was no plot. Literally the only point of the drama was that something tragic happened, they fixed it and momentary happiness came, then it started all over again, and I got bored of it after like the 4th episode. But ironically, I think the show was a bit self aware, because the last episode ended with another upcoming tragedy lol, so it was really an endless loop. Also this break up get back together shit was boring too. And like damn, okay they got back together in the end, but because the 2 guys stayed in the army I think their relationship won't last long again lmao. The only reason I still finished it was really only because of the cast and the cinematography, but I would definitely never watch it again, and I consider it to be one of the worst dramas I've seen.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Acting/Cast
I don't think I have to say anything about this. Song Joong Ki is not only a good looking guy but also very talented (everyone who watched his previous work should now that).
This was the first time I saw Song Hye Kyo in a drama and I really liked her as well, she's a very good actress imo
Music
I absolutely loved the OST's for this drama and even downloaded some of them.
Story
The story is the only part were it lacked a bit, mainly because the whole drama wasn't as connected as it could've been. A few episodes were always tied together but then it felt like the whole things before never happened and a new chapter began. Nevertheless it was a good mixture of a hospital, military/action and romance drama.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
When this show came out, it became immediately super popular, for several reasons: the cast (especially for Song Joon Ki and Song Hye Kyo), the setting, the pre-production. Basically, you couldn't even dare to try to find a flaw without risking to be virtually crucified. In my opinion, it has many good points. Song Joon Ki and Song Hye Kyo have lots of chemistry (no wonder they became a real-life couple afterwards) and are simply perfect. They're also supported by an amazing cast. The setting (aka mostly the Greek island of Zante) is obviously beautiful and cinematography is quite good. All the characters are very much enjoyable. The bromance is adorable.
My biggest complaint, though, is the plot. The show drags itself out quite a lot, sometimes it's even openly boring. If you remove the special effects and all the aforementioned reasons, I agree that what you get is a lame story which, acted and directed by someone else, probably would have never get the same attention.
Overall, a good though overrated show. Nothing that will make you write home about.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The drama “Descendants of the Sun” opened for me the world of Korean cinema, and with it the culture of the Korean people. And now I listen to the replay soundtrack and eagerly read blogs about life in Korea. The first two episodes stunned me. I suddenly saw unusual behavior of people: nods as a gesture of greeting. A stretched O, expressing surprise or irony. The increased physical distance between people in a communication situation compared to the distance accepted in our culture. Rare touches of lovers. But gradually I ceased to notice all these differences, and they became natural for me, as if in a different way it does not happen.
In contrast to the often caustic western cinema, the Korean drama creates a romantic-vanilla mood. Koreans are not bored to take off and watch about how a man tying shoelaces for his woman, making a cup of coffee for her, putting her hair in her tail. I understand that this is a drama, that in life they are far from always the case. But the drama serves as a good guide for people - this is what we should strive for. Western cinema shows a lot of dirt, people watch and begin to consider it the norm. And Korean cinema glorifies the right values.
I admire the shown ideal of relations between people, at the heart of all relations is mutual respect. “Descendants of the Sun” provide an example of what should be the relationship between a man and a woman, between a boss and a subordinate, older in age and younger, between a man and his profession, what friendship should be.
Despite the fact that the drama has a lot of romance and humor, there is a place for realism in it. I'm not talking about the amazing combination of circumstances that the characters face. What only heroes have not passed! And an earthquake, and a fall from a cliff by car, and a walk through a minefield, and much more. I’m talking about such aspects of public relations as blooming corruption and dragging their “protégés” to good positions, unreasonable orders of stupid bosses, ugly hysterical behavior of some people.
As for the relationship of lovers, the lack of bed scenes caught my eye. Romantic relationships are platonic. Korean couples walk by the arms, hug and kiss each other, maximum on the forehead. Maybe this is an illusion created in the cinema, or maybe, indeed, Korean society is more chaste? In any case, thanks to this, the relationship between Yu Si Jin and Ka Mo Yong, like So Do Yoon and Yu Men Jin, became even more sublime and emotional. You begin to appreciate every touch, every gentle look.
In the end, I really wanted to see the marriage proposal after all that the heroes had to go through. The wedding would be, as they say, "a cherry on the cake." What did not happen in the drama followed in real life. It is insanely pleasant that the on-screen love of Song Joon Ki and Song Hye Kyo has grown into a real relationship and marriage. They are just perfect for each other and very very beautiful.
Other viewers wrote wonderful reviews of the drama, examined the advantages and disadvantages of the plot, far and wide, so I will not repeat it. I will say one thing, watch this movie. It will bring you many benefits and bright feelings.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
IMMATURE ACTING.... (KNOWING SOME ARE VETERAN ACTORS, it's like a downgrade to their performance)...
MUSIC IS OKAY, this could've been better a music video....
A WASTE OF TIME ON YOUR VIEWING HABITS..
http://www.koreaboo.com/kdrama/netizens-claim-new-k-drama-descendants-of-the-sun-is-completely-overrated/
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Several friends recomemmened me watch this drama, also I saw that in Korea was really popular. However now I finally can finished this dramas after long long time, I started around 6 months or more really excited because I heard before the OST and was amazing I'm fan of Kwill and his song is so nice also obviously Joong ki is another handsome motivation for watching.BUT I need to say that the story is so boring or better they dont have plot ... is just a mix between war, military, doctors without a coherent plot , with a few funny situations.
Also Yoo Shi Jin (main role) is so ridiculous arrogant and in some situation really womanizer that for me was really annoying, for many reasons I paused several times this drama... long time trying to finish but always the episodes didnt hook me and problematic situation repeted and repeted.
I dont want to post spoiler for your understand me, Definitely I can't recommend this drama.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
What I absolutely loved (aside from Song Hyegyo who I've been a fan of since Autumn in My Heart) is how the storyline wasn't as cliched as most dramas! It was actually realistic and, yes, cheesy. The reason it wasn't like other dramas is because it was.. truthful.
When you see someone that good looking would you really fall for their heart at first sight? No, that's just a fairytale. I think that's what caught my attention about this from the first episode on.
(P.S. I'm usually very picky about the music in dramas but I gave this one a 10 because of XIA Junsu, I'll be honest.)
In conclusion, it's a great drama that is definitely worth your time!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
One thing that really put this drama over the top is the pacing of the stories. It's really hard for a k-drama to pace itself sometimes, but this one flowed along right on schedule. Also it's hard to follow a main characters story, but not only did it follow them to fulfillment but the rest of the cast also. On top of that it had a secondary main couple, and it didn't skimp on that story line or push it too fast in order to not compromise the main.
A lot of doctors did scoff at the likelihood of some of the medical happenings, but I stand by what I watched. Though improbable, there are always times when the impossible must be attempted so I can see how it might have a millionth of a chance of happening.
The music was sublime, and the plot points were entertaining and thrilling. There wasn't a moment of this drama that I fast forwarded through. ( I sometimes do that). My biggest thing with K-dramas as opposed to american shows is that I tend to re-watch my american stuff, but I am happy just watching a Korean drama once and calling it good. However, this particular drama rates so high with me that I want to buy it and re-watch it at times. I have only had 3 other dramas out of the literal hundreds that I've watched that I can say are on that list.
The biggest thing that totally had me flying was the relationship between the main characters. And I cannot stress it enough....the KISSING :) I am a big person about the kiss in K-dramas or any show in particular. There were no awkward closed lip push, or one doing a deep french with the tight lipped closed mouth.
The silent communications for all the couples mirror real life. All the things you want to say but cant, and all the things that you are sorry for but can't apologize correctly. You feel it all, and it is breathtaking. I highly recommend watching this drama, and nobody will be dissatisfied.....It really is worth the watch.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
This drama is totally about love life of a soldier and doctor who fall in love at first sight. All the dangerous things that they'll go through together and how they love story will end up that's what this drama told about. I rate it at 9 because the writer wrote the story way too good. It's light story, entertaining. Well that's the reason we watch drama rite? To be entertained :) This drama includes many cheesy lines which told in different way. One of my fave is "Should I apologize or confess my love?". I rate it at 9 because I read article about the reason why Kim Eun Sook and Kim Won Seok decide to not put triangle love inside it. I thought their decision was right. I'm totally bored with classic love story k-drama which is the main character will hate each other first and then they'll fall in love, or chaebol love story with triangle love. DOTS offers you something different and fresh. You'll regret if you missed it. (everytime you end one episode you'll be curious about what happens next, the production team edited the preview in smart way. so when you already start you'll never stop haha :p)
Cast :
- SJK : This is the first time I watch his drama and he totally steal my heart. He worked so hard to play YSJ. I mean he struggles on every single action scenes without stuntman. Even he got injured a month before last shoot and tried to started again 2 weeks later. His decision to pick this drama as his first project after out from military was right. Definitely right. He's good at acting. I'm waiting for his next project.
- SHK : I admire her acting quality. She brings out the emotional side of KMY way too good. I even can cry when tears came out from her eyes. She's definitely not just beautiful but also good in acting. I'm also waiting for her next project.
- JG : I never knew him. I mean he never showed up in drama that I watch. I thought he hasn't married yet hahaha He also will be a shining star this year. He did a good job to play SDY :)
- KJW : Yoo Racheeeeel! I ever watch her acting in Heirs. But I don't like her character and heirs's plot (sorry kim eun sook). But KJW as YMJ? She's perfectly got it. She even cut her hair to become a woman soldier. I'm waiting her new drama with Seo In Guk :)
For conclusion the cast of DOTS is the best cast that a drama could have. I have no hesitate to give it 10 out of 10.
OST :
I watch many drama before DOTS. But having all of the OST on my playlist and repeat it in every my spare time? Only DOTS's OST can do it. This drama also has best ost I ever hear. All of it was easy listening and perfect. My fave is K.Will Talk Love and Chen,Punch with Everytime.
Rewatch Value :
Even when the drama hasn't finished yet I watch last episode while waiting the next one. So it's definitely 9 out of 10 to rewatch.
Overall this drama was good for you who wants to be entertained by light story. Who needs cheesy things but not the cheap one. Who needs jokes to release your stressful feeling. Who wants to see how SJK acts as cool and cute soldier :)
HAPPY WATCHING!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
So much about this drama is a refreshing change to Korean drama. For one thing, part of the story takes place in a fictional country, played by Greece. I haven't been so excited about a location change since Jan Di and Jun Pyo went to New Caledonia in "Boys Over Flowers".
Another refreshing element is the juxtaposition of the careers of a soldier and a doctor. Additionally, they become romantically involved, despite that some aspects of their occupations will never mesh. Song Joong Ki and Song Hye Kyo were excellent in the leading roles and were fondly referred to as "Song Song Couple" by fans of the show.
A third great aspect of "Descendants Of The Sun" ("DoTS') is that supporting characters get their own story lines and don't exist just to make the OTP look good. Jin Gu as Sgt. Seo and Kim Ji Won as Dr. Yoon have their own relationship trajectory. Shinee's Onew as Lee Chi Hoon and Kim Min Suk as Pvt. Kim Ki Bum and others have their own storylines that tie into those of the TTP (Two True Pairs).
Fourth, the female leads are shown as competent in their professions. In so many dramas, the female(s) are seen as incompetent in their jobs, only to be rescued in the end by their heroic men.
Drs. Yoon and Kang were presented throughout the dramas as professionals ably performing their jobs, despite difficult decisions that had to be made.
A few more details that just were icing on the cake....an Anglo that could actually act, David McGinnis as Agus, a good guy gone bad; and Dr. Kang's BFF was a wheelchair user.
The soundtrack was great and many of the songs became popular among fans.
Unlike many dramas that start and end well but sag in the middle, this drama kept the plot going through all 16 episodes. It was very enjoyable to watch and I'd put it on the desert island short list, those I'd watch if I had a limited supply to take to a desert island. Because who knows...someone might actually film a drama there!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
