Maravilhoso
Sinceramente não pensei que fosse gostar tanto, mas me vi presa por desde o início. A história claramente possui dois arcos (sendo o primeiro a premissa do Nok Du se vestir de mulher e entrar na vila pras viúvas, e depois toma um ar mais sério em que várias intrigas começam a se desenrolar de fato). O casal é maravilhoso. Sério, assistir eles fez o meu dia. Extremamente fofos e o relacionamento deles é muito bem construído. Eles tem muito tempo de tela juntos e é possível sentir o quanto eles se gostam sem diálogos expositivos. Algo que me agradou muito foi que eles demonstraram ter uma um relacionamento muito embasado em uma verdadeira amizade, o que faz com que o espectador (pelo menos eu) sentisse toda a intimidade entre eles. Eles se sentem completamente confortáveis um com o outro (o que faz eles se irritarem bastante, mas é tudo muito bonitinho) e acho isso incrível.Enfim, o plot da origem do Nok Du me emocionou muito, mas o fim foi sinceramente perfeito. Não teria outra forma das coisas se resolverem (mas vou parar por aqui pra não dar spoiler).
Foi maravilhoso de assistir e aproveitei cada momento.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Aprendi a gostar muito de dramas históricos – sageuks –, e esse não peca em nada; muito pelo contrário, acrescenta e me deu mais opiniões a respeito do gênero. Ele passeia pelas tretas palacianas bem comuns, mas sem deixar de ser divertido ou desviar do objetivo.
Nok Du é um garoto que vive numa pacata ilha com o pai e o irmão e não tem a mínima noção de que o pai esconde alguns segredos. Mas quando a família é atacada por assassinos sendo que nunca fizeram mal a ninguém, um instinto o move tomar uma atitude para descobrir o que está por detrás do acontecimento. E quando chega na cidade encontra Dong Jo, uma garota que tem a intenção de matar o rei com uma flechada.
O encontro característico do casal principal além de proposital, já deixa ás claras que ninguém na trama é privilegiado. Como uma ginsaeng em treinamento, Dong Jo está aprendendo a arte de agradar os homens, e vive num vilarejo para viúvas. E é assim que Nok Du tem a grandiosa ideia de se vestir de mulher, fazendo com que a trama vire um gender bender, que é quando um personagem veste roupas do sexo oposto.
Sou suspeita em falar desse gênero que é pouco utilizado e eu amo, mas que já teve seus momentos de glória no mundo asiático. Foi bom ver esse retorno e o vi com outros olhos. Meu primeiro drama da vida foi Coffee Prince, só que era uma menina sendo um garoto e a maioria dos gender bender são assim; então, ver a atuação excepcional do Dong Yoon foi uma lufada de ar fresco. Ele realmente entrou no personagem e era possível ver a modulação da voz, o treino físico para atuar como mulher dando vida a Lady Kim. Que talento!
Nosso protagonista entra em várias trapalhadas enquanto tenta manter o disfarce e ainda investigar o que tem de tão diferente na vila das viúvas, mas sem deixar que Dong Joo tenha um papel importante em muitas das cenas. Ela é uma personagem que não perde em nada, tem seu destaque na trama e um passado triste, por isso seus motivos em matar o rei.
Não posso esquecer de comentar que o poder feminino desse dorama é enorme. Ao criar uma vila de viúvas, a roteirista deu destaque a vida de mulheres que após a perda do marido são praticamente deixadas de lado pela família e precisam dar um jeito de ganhar o sustento. E mesmo não podendo me estender para não soltar nenhum spoiler, o que está por trás da vila também tem seu próprio empoderamento.
Quero também dar destaque ao Yool Mu por ter uma paixão pela Dong Joo e ser a outra ponto dentro do triângulo amoroso dessa história. Não gosto da temática, mas eu mudei de ideia, pois aqui ele é vital. Além dele se mostrar um personagem diferente. Kang Tae Oh protagonizou as duas temporadas de My First First Love na Netflix e gosto muito da atuação dele. E não só ele, tem muitos atores bons nesse dorama, é um dos pontos positivos de sageuk: conhecer vários atores. Outra fofura é a Aeng Do, uma menininha apaixonada pelo Nok Du, vocês vão concordar comigo se assistirem.
As tretas no palácio são excelente! Creio que The Tale of Nokdu tem um dos melhores plot twist em sageuk que já tive o prazer em assistir em um sageuk. Um bom modo de mostrar como a ambição tem seus meios equivocados.
Fico imensamente grata em dizer que o final desse dorama é maravilhoso. Um lindo felizes para sempre. E eu não pediria menos que isso, pois o romance do casal foi muito bem construído ao longo dos episódios e dá para sentir como eles se importam um com o outro. A química tava lá e veio recheada de demonstrações de afeto e beijinhos, para o alívio da nação dorameira.
Assistam!! Tenho certeza que quando começar você vai piscar e daqui a pouco acabar. É muito bom!
Até a próxima! ⤳
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
And I couldn't deny that the best part of this drama was the acting of, and chemistry between, all the actors. Props to all cast members, including the director and staff with the beautiful sceneries and cinematography. But of course, I have to say this out loud: Jang Dongyoon and Kim Sohyun's chemistry was heckin exploding!!!! I just love them both!!!!! I was pretty much lukewarm with Kim Sohyun before, but I'm a fan now. And don't get me started with Jang Dongyoon—he's just too good to be true! Very much looking forward to their next projects, and I really really hope they do another project together. Maybe not in the near future, but hopefully someday, when they're a bit older. It's been a long time since I wanted to ship lead actors and wished for them to date in real life, but I just can't help it. These two look cute together and I am deluding myself into believing that they can't act like that if they didn't have real feelings..... or maybe they're just really good. Either way, I am fine with that! <3
OST and sound effects were great for me as well. I just wished they didn't use songs with repetitive English lines (but the "one of a kind girl" kinda grew on me eventually haha). I love the all-Korean songs, like Younha's Shine On You. I had it on repeat since it became available on Spotify. Became a feel good song for me since it reminded me of all the Nokdu-Dongjoo soft happy moments.
Rewatch value—definitely watching this again! Just until I get over my Jang Dongyoon-Kim Sohyun feels.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Another Level of Romantic Comedy Drama
At first I watched this drama, I actually think it would be a cross-dressing drama when the male lead would hard to convince the female lead about his real gender HAHAHA. But silly me, I am expected this drama way too low than the actual story. I must say that the drama is EPIC, the plot, the acting, the soundtrack, especially the unexpected villain are all ON POINT. Never expect this much for romantic comedy drama (who turns out to be melo in the second half of the drama).I love how this drama put the right song in the right scene, and make you remember that scene a lot because it was totally beautiful (especially the rain scene, the swing, and the fight scene).
I feel like a butterfly fulling my stomach after I finished watching this drama, and I know I would miss Dong Joo - Nok Du couple much. The parents-children relationship also getting me in tears much, applause to Jang Dong Yoon who brings the sad scene greatly, because when he's in tears, I feel my tears suddenly flows too. Such a great actor! Kim So Hyun acting is unquestionable, because she's veteran anyway.
For me, I am positively would re-watch this drama, because the story is so interesting (and probably would be hard to move on like I did in 100 days my prince), and Jang Dong Yoon is so handsome and pretty at the same time, it's like one package of cinnamon roll he is.
They have great chemistry on or off screen (you should watch behind the scene by the way). You know, the drama is successful if we want them together in real life, it's just exactly what we want for JDY and KSH HAHAHAH
If you haven't watched the drama yet, I think you should give it a try. If you expect the light rom-com which we could expect where the story would leads us, then you won't have it in Tale of Nokdu. Because, as I said before, this drama is another level of romantic comedy drama (in general) and would make you goose-bumped in every episode.
P.S : you will love our beloved and sassy Lady Kim
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
There is some compelling narrative going on that makes me stay in the third act, but alas I think the writers is not interested to unfold it better.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The characters of the leads were, in my opinion, tedious and immature and their dialogue was a rinse and repeat of the same childish phrases which turned the romance really shallow.
The king despite being cruel was the most interesting character in the drama and I liked him more than any other character.
The ending was laughable and without much substance to be honest. Without spoiling I'll say that I don't understand how could they live happily with a dark cloud over their heads that can rain down at any time and wash away their peace.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
A Mess And The Worst Ending
It had a great start, the village of widows and the male lead's shenanigans were very entertaining. The acting was good.Then the romance started and things started going off the rails. While the comedy aspect was dialed down to let the narrative take a darker turn, the romance felt out of place due to its childish nature, the male lead seemed to switch personalities in the romance scenes. The main characters turned unlikeable because their intentions were so vague, especially the female lead's goal which I found so ridiculous. I even started rooting for the supposed vilain(the King) that was more interesting.
The romance consisted of miscommunication, cheesy lines that are repeated a hundred times and childish fights(i like u, wait, no i dont like u, i have to leave u now blablabla), I cringed everytime. I saw no reason for them to love eachother so strongly right from episode 4 or 5. It took too long for them to talk about their goals. By the final episode the romantic lines lost all impact because they were repeated so often. The female lead should've been the assassin lady, a more interesting character and more relevant to the plot, which would have made a more cohesive and original narrative.
And the worst of all:
Nokdu shouldn't have temporarily worked with the prince to betray the King, instead he should've dealt with the King in a different manner(because deep down he still had some good in him) but no, instead Nokdu went to live in an isolated island "happily ever after" while the King was then ambushed by the prince to start his reign of terror. What about the kingdom and its people? The fact that it ended with the prince as king was the worst ending possible, how can I believe that they lived happily ever after knowing that they left such a cruel man on the throne of the country? What if he finds out where they are?
Even if he never finds out where they are, how is a life in hiding (which Nokdu's brother hated so much and made their mother die), happy?
At least, they should've addressed them going back to that miserable life with seriousness or if it's too much too ask at least with one line or something, not with a silly half episode and the ending card "and they lived happily ever after"
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Boring
Likes1. I liked the sword fight scenes esp when Muwol Corps are fighting.
2. Nokdu and Dongju were a nice pair!
3. The Queen, Yunjo and Heo who tried their best to persuade the King to not kill the child.
4. The old master who was always by Nokdu's side (i was scared that he will die in the last scene)
5. The middle half when Yulmo revealed his identity and the plans for revolt starting happening. I was more interested in the political part rather than the widow village scenes.
6. The happy ever after at the end! ? and the Queen gets to live with the couple too!! Dont even care what happens to the King!
Dislikes
1. The first half was funny but then it got boring because there was not a lot of action happening and the leads just keep talking in every scene. I fast forwarded some scenes ? unfortunately.
2. The King was awful and Prince Neungyang too but we know he will end up with the throne. So half of the time im asking, why waste 16 episodes just to find out the bad guy wins? Then i realize the title is called The Tale of Nokdu so it's not about the throne but about Nokdu's growth.
Rating: 7.5/10
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
CLICHE, POORLY WRITTEN, DRAGGY
story- romcom for the first 4 episodes then for the next 15 episodes it just rising action (building conflict) and then an episode with the climax and falling action. and just when you thought the resolution will comes next they decided to bring back the conflict just before everything ended. with a poorly written conclusion the writers just destroyed everything that they were trying to build for like almost all of the series' time. on the other hand, the viewers will feel like they just wasted their time watching this because their wasn't a clear and logical outcome from the conflict. the conflict was just like their as a vehicle to lengthen the story and not as a device to develop the characters. they shoul've just sticked to their rom com genre. well all of this could've happen because the writers couldn't think of anything to do to strecth the story so they started screwing things up by making this a cliche, poorly written and draggy series.acting- well the acting is the only saving grace of this series. if you managed to watched this up until the end, it's most probably because the cast acted really well.
music- nothing memorable
rewatch value- this series took so much time building up a conflict to only ruin it without having any resolution. you're just gonna question how the writers managed to drag a conflict for so long and then made you felt like it was all for nothing, because literally nothing happened after the conflict. rewatching this is just a waste of time all over again.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
It was SO good
It was really good and then became a complete disappointment. I was not satisfied with the ending. However, I laughed throughout the series. The writers did a great job of giving the audience enough joy along with some tears. I didn't have any happy tears, but the love plot was romance and intense. I enjoyed that along with the storyline until the last 3 or 4 episodes. You're going to have to watch it and leave a comment on how you felt about the ending. If anything, I believe the writers can get a season 2 out of this storyline.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
hmmm is this Hwarang?
I started watching this drama because it was recommended to me on Netflix so much and.... i wasnt the biggest fan of it. There are a few issues i have with this drama but the biggest one is the storyline.The story is about Jeon Nok Du, who was raised by an adoptive family far away from the "main" city. Once people who were close to him (his family) was attacked he decided to find the person responsible. ML was not properly educated but somehow he understood/learnt things quickly. In order to find the responsible person, he pretends to be someone else " hiding right in front of the king". He learns that the king/prince is to blame. Later we find out that actually he is the prince and can be crowned the next king but.... instead he choses to live a calm life with the FL. Reminds anyone of something?
In the series, as soon as they said sth among the lines of "hiding from the king right under his nose", i realised that this series was ridiculously similar to Hwarang. The only difference was that the ML was pretending to be a woman in the widow village rather than pretending to be a part of a king's army. Even at the end, he doesn't chose to be the king and decided to have a calm life with the FL. Similarities were so obvious and made me question why producers of Hwarang didn't sue them for plagiarism...
I understand that kdramas tend to have some similarities. Many romcoms follow the same development: both ML and FL dont know each other/ hate each other, then sth happens and they either work/live together, they slowly develop feelings for each other, on ep 8 or 9 they kiss for the first time, then they find out they have a childhood connection ( usually trauma) etc. However, different dramas, even when using the same development, have different feel to it. Actors play their roles in a certain way, some plots are different, etc. But here, even phrases that characters used were the same. Felt as if they took Hwarang scripts and made a few modifications (ML hides in the widow house) and thats it.
Another issue i had with this drama were the 2 different story lines where ML and FL were both after the king. The lack of synergy between those made some moments unenjoyable to say the least. When the ML was trying to execute his plan to kill the king, FL looked absolutely stupid with her strategies and aims. Thus i couldn't bare to watch her scenes where shes working so hard on her "amazing" plan while it looks absolutely pathetic in comparison to the plan of the ML.
Also the ending of the drama felt forced. Like producers were out of ideas and they made this up to end it. Why didn't Nok Du become a king? Why did the other guy (the prince) did? Why did ML&FML just HAVE TO move god knows where? Whats the point? whats up with his mom coming all the way to their island to seem them?
I guess the strongest part of the series was the romance/chemistry between the ML and FL. At least that was enjoyable to watch until she found out that he was the kings son and was just cold to him. This moment felt very 2010 romance kdrama to me. Nowadays, characters communicate more with each other so this " i found out sth bad about u so i must break up with u and i will never tell u why" trope is less common (thank god!). Also the cross dressing thing was funny.
Overall, this drama was ok ish and mainly because it felt like a rip off of Hwarang. They didn't add any value to the story line, didnt really make it "theirs". I finished it for the sake of finishing it and i wouldn't be rewatching it. Actors did a good job acting but sadly even that didn't help.
btw, Its been a few weeks since i watch the drama so i could be misremembering some small things.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Overall, I genuinely enjoyed the first 2/3 of this drama much more than the last 1/3 (though the last episode wrapped things up nicely, with the balance I found so enjoyable in the first 2/3 of the story). The first 2/3 were entertainingly comedic with cute relationships building. The last 1/3 was much darker with all the fighting over the thrown and people trying to take their revenge, which makes logical sense, but I missed the light antics from the series that seemed to be lost in the political struggles towards the end.
The OST was pleasant. Actors were also enjoyable, but no one really stood out to me one way or another. I'll likely never rewatch this drama, especially with how difficult it was for me to finish the last couple of episodes. Would I recommend it? Hmmm. It wasn't a bad drama... If the trailers intrigue you, give it a shot, if they don't, I don't necessarily think you're missing anything.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?