Esta resenha foi útil para você?
What makes this drama so great, from the very beginning, is the four lead characters. As much as i loved the romance in Sungkyunkwan Scandal (including what's now one of my favorite k-drama kiss scenes), I still loved the bromance between all four main characters more. Yoo Ah In as the impetuous rebel Moon Jae Shin, Micky Yoochun as the logic driven bookworm Lee Sun Joon, Park Min Young as the inspiringly ambitious "Kim Yoon Shik", and (my favorite) Song Jung Ki as the playfully manipulative Goo Yong Ha, are each outstanding in their role, and have amazing chemistry with each other. There were even times when the chemistry between Moon Jae Shin & Goo Yong Ha rivaled the main couple.
I also have to give a special mention to Kim Min Seo as Cho Sun, who was my favorite supporting character, and played her part expertly. It was really refreshing to see two strong female characters, especially since the story revolves around an all boys school. This is now among my favorite all time dramas, mainly because of the cast. I loved them so much, I was tempted to rewatch the entire drama right after I finished it.
One small criticism I have is that the political part of the plot was sometimes hard for me to follow, since korean history is completely (and literally) foreign to me. This is not really a fault of the drama, but it did stop me from personally seeing this as a perfect 10. It became much easier for me to follow the noron/soron conflicts after a while, but I could still enjoy the drama without being 100% clear. There's a good amount of action, and mystery, which keeps the political plot entertaining.
Another criticism is, as much as I liked the endings for the 4 main characters, there were still unanswered questions, and some supporting characters that deserved better endings.
Overall, there was much more to praise than criticize. I can definitely see myself rewatching this multiple times, even if it's just to see Goo Yong Ha spin. I know there are many dramas with similar plots, but a drama that's entertaining from the 1st to the last episode is rare. I recommend Sungkyunkwan Scandal as one of those rare dramas.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Story- Very intense throughout. I liked not exactly knowing what was going to happen next. I liked that it took place in different settings. It helped to keep the story fresh and watchable till the end. The episodes have a good pace. The wea point of the story would be the romance. It was kind of not believable at certain times just because Cho In was so obsessed with the first gf for a long time. Solid ending.
Acting/cast- Solid acting by the 4 leads. So Ji Sub was very good at playing both the Dr. and Young Ji’s fake cousin. He pulled off the two different characters well. Now even though the acting was top notch, I just could not get invested in the characters. First, I was turned off by So Ji Sub’s character in the beginning. His decision to date his older brother's love just because he had been gone a while, just didn’t sit right with me. Now as odd as it sounds, I actually was rooting for the villain Sun Woo. Yes he did unforgivable things but I kind of understood where he was coming from. I was rooting for him to see the light and be reunited with Seo Yeon. Ha Ji Min’s character was sooo annoying. Not only was her North Korean accent she had throughout annoying but also her actions just made her character not likeable. She also asks too many questions! Let’s just say it was really hard to root for her. I liked the supporting cast. The villains were villainy and the side Dr. couple was funny/cute.
Music- it fit the scenes but I didn’t really like it.
Rewatch- I don’t think I’ll be watching this again but it is rewatchable.
Overall, on the surface Cain and Abel is a high quality drama but I just didn’t get that feeling you get by the end when you really enjoyed a drama and are sad to see it end.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
To start out, I really enjoyed the first few episodes. I would start to lose interest, and the writers would lure me back in with love triangle(s) and the like. However, I have some real bones to pick...
I feel like this drama was about 4 episodes too long. The plot line started to get really diluted, and I couldn't even keep track of what was happening. Early in the drama, it was obvious that there were 4 main characters. I wish that they wouldn't have wasted the viewers time with the others (I realize this won't be a popular opinion). Frankly, I didn't care for the secondary cast (especially the teachers--minus the guidance counselor). In saying this, I just wanted the 4 mains to be fleshed out more. I wanted to know more about Lian and JB.
I didn't know who to root for concerning the JB-HyeSung-YooJin triangle. I could see Lian's frustration. Yeah, Lian was a nasty jerk-- But at least she wasn't annoying. I thought JB and HyeSung were cute, but then I felt bad for YooJin. I don't know, I just feel as though I'm ranting.
I just felt that certain story lines were really muted. The ending felt really rushed, and didn't make a lot of sense. I stuck with this drama because every time I felt like dropping it, they would give me a little ray of hope. I'm very confused by the ending. And disappointed.
:P
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Shut Up: A Banda de Garotos Bonitos
11 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
But it went all wrong -.-
Bad:
The guys were all pretty much the same, no character stood out from the band. The support charas too and the main girl was a typical good girl. No character development.
The story didn´t reach any peak and was predictable. Even the cliffhanger didn´t get me (every week i watched rather Dream High 2 first than this).
The pairings had no chemistry at all. I still can´t understand why someone liked the other.
Good:
The guys looks great :3
The music was listenable ^^
Lee Min Ki was great as Joo Byung Hee, unfortunately he had only a guest role.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Story: I watched it because when I read the description, it "sounded" interesting. But having watched this when I was new to dramas, I was in for a surprise and not necessarily a pleasant one.
Acting/Cast: It was horrible. There was a lot of overacting by everyone.
Music: The music was fairly decent. I still listen to one song from the OST, "Bitter Tea".
Re-watch: I never plan on watching this again and I honestly don't recommend it to anyone.
Overall: I watched this when dramas were bright and shiny for me and when I didn't drop dramas. If had I watched this now, it would have been dropped by episode 2 at the most. Or more likely, I wouldn't have even bothered with it.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
I quite liked the music in it, and Hello to Myself has became a favourite song of mine. But JB as an actor is pretty bad. He's adorable, has a lovely smile, a decent singing voice, and can clearly dance. So for an idol, he's perfect. Just don't try acting again, JB. Jinwoon and JiYeon did a decent-ish job, as did Kang Sora. I mean, there were no spectacular actors in this show so at least they didn't have people comparing them to each other. They all got to be mediocre together.
I don't necessarily think I wasted over 16 hours of my life on this drama, but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Acting/Cast - The two main characters fit well together. I fell in love with their bond. Cast was chosen well and Ki Joon gives off the appearance of a true businessman.
Music - Personally, I didn't notice it too much since it blended well with the drama. When I did notice, the songs were nice to listen to and go well with the scene playing at that time.
Overall - I was watching two fully aired dramas at once. This one took precedence over the other.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Drama Special Season 2: Hwapyeong Princess's Weight Loss
11 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Shut Up: A Banda de Garotos Bonitos
4 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
-The characters fit really well with each other and were written well.
-The acting was better than I initially expected.
-Music was catchy and interesting
Bad:
-Background information and the actions taken throughout the drama based on that information was lacking. Found myself put off or confused once in a while.
-Plot was good, but not the greatest. It didn't get me addicted to the drama.
Overall: This is a good drama worth watching if you like music.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Acting/cast - The casting was good. The most developed characters would be Rian and Jin Yoo Jin. Rian is an amazing actor.
I was anticipating Kang So Ra to suddenly surprise everyone (maybe a little dramatic haha) - A big let down. Her acting wasn't unbearable/too bad, but her character was nothing outstanding and I found myself forgetting about her (even though she has enough screen time for a main) till the very end.
Music - This drama is good primarily for the music. All the songs that were used are amazing and catchy. I would definitely recommend if you are going to watch for the music and dancing. There are some amazing vocals in this drama.
Overall - It was a decent school drama. The plot was the only thing really bringing the quality down, but the music makes up for that.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Shut Up: A Banda de Garotos Bonitos
5 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
The Storyline was executed brilliantly; take a basic structure of what you need to make a fantastic drama, add that with a serious dose of great music, and top it if off with a great cast...what do you get?
A GREAT DRAMA!
I enjoyed every bit of it, but what I liked the most was the pace in which the drama had, every single scene was understandable, nothing was rushed and you could tell the plot was well thought through. I was completely engrossed into this drama and loved every bit of it!
I really wanted to be critical with my scoring, but having judged this drama against it's own kind (i.e. Music band drama's) This was so worth every mark awarded...I can't speak for you, so all I can say to you is Shut up and watch (^_^)/
Esta resenha foi útil para você?