its 5 star fo me.. STORYLINE.. THE CHEMISTRY BETWEEN THE MAIN LEAD WAS TOP NOTCH .. WE CAN FEEL ALL THE EMOTION.. and cheng yi was really good expressing his feeling.. he has soulfull eyes.. that you can feel all the emotion just through his powerfull eyes.. and yuan bing yan also get along with him very well.. it can be said that the essence of this whole drama was their BEAUTIFULL AND LOVELY CHEMISTRY along with their GREAT ACTING potraying their character.. in conclusion its BEAUTIFULL, PEFECT AND HEART WRENCHING STORY .. it took me 6 month to move on from this drama and start watching other cdrama.. and also ad a big fan of xianxia drama.. this is A PERFECT AND TOP XIAN XIA DRAMA so far for me.. THE REWATCH VALUE was not full just because this drama so long so its hard to rewatch again.. just will rewatch good scene not whole of them..