The acting is good and characters in the storyline are great. Overcoming the the feeling of hatred towards the person you believed have done bad in your life, turning it into something special and bringing deeper relationship between the leads. I so love how the male lead slowly falls inlove despite the anger kept within.
Praise to the writer for the story plot.
Give points to the director which result to good ratings and multiple awards and nominations.
overall ... i love this kdrama...
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
This drama defined the thin line between love and hate.
Started this drama for Ji Sung after watching Kill me, Heal me. He's an AMAZING actor and I loved the chemistry between the main leads.I LOVED this drama. Didn't like the stupidly of the FL at first, but after 4 episodes, I started to like her more.
Music: Perfect. All the sound tracks went so well with all the scenes, it made them so much more dramatic and let you feel the tension.
This drama really shows you the thin line between love and hate. It shows the difference between love and obsession and love that starts from obsession. The opposite of Wuthering Heights.
Main Leads (Min Hyeok and Yoo Jung): I loved Min Hyeok immediately and throughout. I also loved Yoo Jung, she grew on me, but at first she was just plain naive and stupid. Min Hyeok and Yoo Jung, though they seem a world apart, especially in the first few episodes, they were really alike. Out of every character in this drama, they were the only two who truly knew how to love another person and sacrifice for them. Min Hyeok was at first obsessed with revenge, but his stalking of Yoo Jung litterally saved her life countless times. He was there for her when no one else was. I found it ironic and quite funny that the person who said they hated Yoo Jung the most, was the person who was always there for her to lean on and rely on. His revenge was an obsession, but his love for her was real unlike the relationship between the second leads.
Second Leads (Do Hoon and Se Yeon): I really liked the Se Yeon at the start (the first half) of this drama. She had a really nice friendship with Min Hyeok whome she was engaged to. She was a really nice person in general, which is why the Do Hoon started obsessing over her. I wouldn't say Do Hoon ever truly loved her because he didn't have the emotional capacity to love. At the start she was simply friendly to the Do Hoon and very clear that she only wanted friendship. But when she started actually siding with the Do Hoon, and not just to make Min Hyeok jealous, I started to dislike her, I HATED her double standards. Her love for Min Hyeok was an obsession, similar to Do Hoon's obsession with her. Her downward spiral was very satisfying though I did find it a pity that such a good person went down as she did. I'd blame it on Do Hoon, but she helped further instigate him by leading him on and telling him to go up the social ladder, entirely so that she can make Min Hyeok jealous. The only satisfaction I found with Se Yeon and Do Hoon's relationship was that they were both pathetically clinging on to each other and using each other, and were both too stupid to realise this.
My favourite quote:
- Min Hyeok after he reads Wuthering Heights says: "Revenge that starts from love ends in tragedy. What I'm curious about is, if it's the opposite, love that starts from revenge, what happens to that?"
- Min Hyeak to Do Hoon (FL's ex) after he starts dating Yoo Jung: "Pitiful bastard. Do you still not know what you've lost?" (He truly appreciated the Yoo Jung, something the Do Hoon didn't have the capacity to do and couldn't fathom why Do Hoon treated her so badly).
Ending (SPOILERS):
The thing I was anticipating the most in this drama is not the main leads ending up together, but the second leads getting what they deserve. I really wanted the Yoo Jung to get her justice and by episode 15 it really seemed like she would. But, I was NOT satisfied with the justice she got. Do Hoon and his mother deserved MUCH worse. They both needed to be punished for EVERYTHING they did, but they didn't. I didn't care much for Se Yeon, the fact that her love wasn't reciprocated and would never have been reciprocated by Min Hyeok was enough for me.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
I'm not a huge fan of melodrama and romance together but however, this drama could be perfectly summarized into two words: A masterpiece. It had some flaws but I'm glad that I watched every last bit of it, although I have had my moments where I was so frustrated and wanted to drop it within the first few episodes, this drama definitely won't fail you once you pick it back up again. Let's start with the actors. I've seen Hwang Jung-eum's acting before in Kill Me Heal Me, but I found her acting in Secret to be more likeable than KMHM. Some people won't like Yoojung's personality at first as people might view her as submissive and somewhat of an idiot but I found Yoojung to be the optimistic but naive girl that by showing her kindness, the world would repay it to her the same way. However, that wasn't the case as she suffered and endured a lot and had a total 180 with her personality to the point where I cried every time she did and felt her pain to the max. Ji Sung did a superb work with portraying the rich but a huge jerk of a guy that thought he could have it all but then started to develop a sense of responsibility for all of his actions, while also having an obsession disorder that I think was portrayed amazingly. Bae Soo-bin and Lee Dae-hee. Amazing. Bae Soo-bin is the definition of the guy whom you thought was the perfect boyfriend to the person whom you wanted to crush him every time you saw him and Dae-hee was the perfect classy but petty second female lead and I couldn't help but want to see more of them. Truly wonderful actors.
The story was a reversal of Wuthering Heights. A love that resulted from revenge that was not an easy plot to realize into a likeable drama like this one, but I was so fascinated with every plot twists and obviously, the 'secrets' that were uncovered, which would make you view the whole drama from a whole new perspective. However my one critic is that the ending was a bit unreal for me and how Se-yeon let go of her grudge so quickly was questionable. The ending was fast-paced and all of Yoojung's problems were all solved and uncovered by themselves, which I thought was going to be bit-by-bit. In spite of that I rooted for the poetic justice that Yoojung has finally received.
The music is amaaazing!! I still get shivers and I have all of the OST's on my playlist, definitely a masterpiece OST that truly convey what each of the couple's are truly feeling. Rewatch value is a 9 for two things: The crying and the melodrama. Even if you rewatched the drama a couple of times you would still sympathize with the characters and cry with Yoojung and that what makes it even more amazing, but not for sensitive hearts like mine haha. ;w;
Overall, this drama is a 10/10. definitely would recommend. If you're looking for a quality drama, quality actors, tear-jerking music that would truly 'steal your heart', a drama to cry your eyes out while still cherishing those happy moments once in while, then definitely go for it. Don't watch it if you're looking for a time-waster or watch it while multitasking cause this drama WILL TAKE UP YOUR ENTIRE SCHEDULE. Seriuously, I binged watched it while i had my finals #sorrynotsorry. :D
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Wow.. Very dramatic but also so beautiful
How can one bear this many dramas ? Maybe because she is loved by far much...A very dramatic melodrama, a tearjecker and at the same time, it was wonderful. Great acting, great story, great lovestory, very well paced, gripping...
I bingewatched it cause I couldn't let go after episode 6. The actors are soooo good and the chemistry between the 2 leads is amazing. It's a story about revenge, hate, family, impossible love... and how far one person is willing to go to keep a lie, how far one is willing to go for love... and how love can save someone.
It's a must watch.
i didn't give the drama a 10 because i'm just a littlfe frustrated by the end, i wanted a little bit more of them together :-)
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
I should've watched sooner - Recommended!
I had this series in my watchlist for quite a while. Finally decided to watch and boy must I tell you I should've watched this sooner. This drama was incredible good despite the fact it's already 10 years old! Now, I actually expected a more rom-com like drama, boy was I wrong. I am not an easy crier I must admit, but I have cried my eyes out for poor Yoo Jung. What she went through was absolutely insane. She has all my respect and I am glad that she could recover from all that trauma. This drama was amazing and I highly recommend watching it.However, there are a couple of things that made me have so many feelings at once. (Emotions slipped a little while typing)
- Ahn Do Hoon (Her ex-fiancé); At first I felt very mixed about him. He wasn't that great of a boyfriend and Yoo Jung was blinded by love and accepted his proposal. He hit a goddamn person and as a prosecutor he still decides to run off? Now, I understand that he must've been scared for the consequences and his job etc. but him just leaving her to die is insane. Letting Yoo Jung pay for HIS actions and not even thinking about stepping forward and instead letting his innocent fiancé go in his place really did it for me. I actually felt bad for him due to the pressure he had to face after all that not anymore. But come on, how could Yoo Jung still think that being together while and after the whole trial + imprisonment was okay like he didn't do anything wrong? She trusted him way too much and it annoyed me so much. After all this bullcrap of his and after he reached a higher title he suddenly acted all high and mighty, it disgusted me so much that each time his face came on screen I had to remain calm not dragging him 100m into the ground. Him threatening both Yoo Jung and Min Hyuk like he isn't the problem of this situation. It was so satisfying to see him on his knees, apologizing like a dog and getting water splashed over him. But Kidnapping Yoo Jung's father because his minf was sharp and regained memories made my blood boil. That man treated him as his own and even forgave him yet fear took over Do Hoon. All I can say is that I'm glad he finally gave in and hope he rots in prison. Props to the actor Bae Soo Bin for being great at his job as actor lol.
- Shin Se Yeon; Incredibly irrelevant. Imo she was just an unnecessary obstacle and I hated the sight of her. Not much to be said about her since I skipped parts of her.
- Do Hoon's mother; What a disgusting witch. Giving her grandson away with the most stupidest reason. She had no right to do so and still thought she did the right thing but visits her grandson as much as she'd like? No wonder Do Hoon turned like that, his mother is as evil and nasty as him. Hated her, absolutely hated her from the beginning. She should serve til death.
- Yoo Jung's father; He knew, he KNEEEEEEEW! Yet kept his mouth shut. It angered me, I get that Do Hoon was like a son to him or whatever but please... I love her father so much but that caught me off guard.
- Girl that hurt San (Forgot her name); AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA. How could she do such thing to a baby and still begging for forgiveness while crying like a baby. Hated her.
- Relationship between that Kwang Min and Min Joo; UH WHAT? It lowkey grossed me out and was so random like I thought he was like 50 and Min Joo like 18. Idk how old they were supposed to be but glad it was only 1 scene of her holding his arm.
- Min Hyuk (I love Ji Sung); I loved him but sometimes he was so intense (I still loved it) but the car scene where he kissed her and just ate her up like it was his last meal seemed kind of like assault as she didn't want to kiss him. I might've misinterpreted it, but that was the only thing that made me go like wow step back.
- San; Not about San himself but I was so sad when Yoo Jung saw her son and wanted him back so bad and I did feel bad for Do Hoon aswell seeing your child with 2 strangers that are his parents must've been so hard to accept for the both of them. Yet I'm glad Yoo Jung chose to let him go and held that family together even though it hurts. It was definitely the right choice but also the hardest.
All negatives aside, I definitely enjoyed watching it and loved the 2 broken hearts reparing eachothers and eventually love eachother ^^ Min Hyuk was so obsessed with her that he fell for her and made her fall for him.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
What A Good Surprise
As the headline says, this drama took me by surprise. I had been going through quite a number of K-dramas prior and was not expecting much from this one. However, I got glued to it from the beginning right to the end. The plot was highly acceptable, the acting was superb and the script intelligent. I found myself not fast forwarding and even rewound some parts to understand the plot more, which is so unlike me.So there you have it. A story about love which started with revenge, electrifying chemistry where Ji Sung (Jo Min Hyeok) did a great job! with Hwang Jung Eun playing Yoo Jeong (lead roles). My heart pounded watching Min Hyeok's hate turning to love for Yoo Jeong.
Supporting roles were also extremely believable by Jung Soo Young (a friend made by Yoo Jeong whilst in prison) and ex boyfriend Ahn Doo Hoon who acted his mean part well. The friendship between Min Hyeok and his assistant Gwang Soo had me laughing quite a bit too. They were cute together.
The Directors had the flow of the drama plotted out really well with no boring moments and enacted in a clever way. I was tensed and looked forward to every scene as the real reason for Yoo Jeong being betrayed unfolded.
A drama worth watching and not to be missed. Ji Sung was fabulous. This would be a drama I would want to watch again real soon.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Drammone vecchio stampo, ma ce ne fossero!
Quando si tratta di drama interpretati da Ji Sung, si va spesso a ricadere nel mio solito discorso: a mio modesto e personalissimo parere, Ji Sung è un dio. Più invecchia e più migliora, sia come viso che come recitazione. Può fare – e ha fatto – qualsiasi cosa, e alla grandissima. La sua capacità di calarsi nei personaggi, di farci percepire le emozioni più sottili o, al contrario, le più devastanti, è qualcosa di magico. Riesce a reggere e a rendere plausibili le situazioni più drammaticamente improbabili. Purtroppo, però, lo ritroviamo spesso a recitare in opere in cui la sceneggiatura è, per certi versi, un po’ “troppo”. Questo show non fa eccezione.Secret (love) è un drama sudcoreano del 2013, per la regia di Baek Sang Hoon (Descendants of the Sun, Love in the Moonlight, The King: Eternal Monarch) e Lee Eung Bok (Descendants of the Sun, Goblin, Mr. Sunshine) e la sceneggiatura di Choi Ho Chul e Yoo Bo Ra, in 16 episodi da circa un’ora ciascuno.
Si narra la storia di un quadrilatero pseudo amoroso. Min Hyuk (Ji Sung) è un ricco rampollo di buona famiglia, futuro erede di una società, collerico e a tratti meschino, riluttante a sposare l’amica Shin Se Yeon (Lee Da Hee), figlia di un politico e impostagli dal padre dispotico, perché ama una ragazza povera. Do Hoon (un ottimo Bae Soo Bin) è un onesto pubblico ministero fresco di nomina, fidanzato con Yoo Jung (una splendida Hwang Jung Eum), una panettiera che l’ha finanziariamente aiutato negli studi. Una notte di pioggia, mentre tornano a casa in auto, Do Hoon segretamente investe e lascia morire la fidanzata di Min Hyuk e alla fine Yoo Jung, fidandosene, per evitare di stroncargli la carriera, propone di dichiarare di essere stata lei alla guida, e finisce per beccarsi 5 anni, anche a causa della persecuzione contro di lei che Min Yuk porterà avanti per molti anni. Uscita di prigione, Yoo Jung scoprirà che le cose sono cambiate e, mentre Min Yuk continuerà ossessivamente a perseguitarla fino ad amarla, dovrà difendersi anche dal vecchio fidanzato e dalla sua famiglia, dalla gelosa Se Yeon e, insomma, un po’ da tutti.
La quantità di disgrazie e mortificazioni assortite che, a mezzo di fatalità o dell’intervento di diverse persone, precipitano sulla povera Yoo Jung, è indescrivibile. Si va – e l’elenco non è esaustivo - dalla carcerazione, alle ferite, alla perdita del figlio, dalla malattia mentale del padre alle umiliazioni assortite e alla continua tensione in cui la tiene Min Yuk, senza dimenticare le pressioni di ogni tipo che le fa l’ex fidanzato, terrorizzato all’idea che vengano scoperte le sue malefatte. La ragazza passa molto tempo a piangere, e Hwang Jung Eum lo fa benissimo, ma non solo: tutta la sua performance è convincente e misurata. Se qualcosa si può rimproverare al personaggio, è il suo continuo bisogno di inchinarsi e di scusarsi con chiunque. Eppure, per moltissimo tempo, nonostante le continue minacce di Do Hoon, rifiuterà di rivelare la verità a Min Yuk. Pare che sacrificio sia la sua parola d’ordine e a volte ci si scopre a sperare che la cambi.
Per contro Min Yuk, che vediamo in principio come un uomo egocentrico e facile alla collera, prono a pericolosi scoppi d’ira e francamente molto infantile, col tempo impara ad apprezzare Yoo Jung e, mentre continua la sua persecuzione con modi spesso da stalker psicopatico, cambia pian piano i suoi interventi, passando dalla punizione alla protezione, man mano che si rende conto che la ragazza è diversa da come se la immaginava e che forse in quella fatidica notte le cose sono andate diversamente dalla verità ufficiale.
Nel frattempo, l’ex onesto pubblico ministero Do Hoon, sentendosi minacciato da Yoo Jung e da Min Yuk, riesce a farsi assumere come avvocato dal padre di lui e ad assumere nella società una posizione di preminenza. Il comportamento sempre più minaccioso e traditore del legale, che si allea con Se Yeon contro Min Yuk e Yoo Jung e sembra disposto a distruggere tutto pur di mantenere nascoste le sue sempre più terribili malefatte, è magnificamente recitato da Bae Soo Bin, veramente superbo in questa parte così repellente. Ha recitato così bene che, sulla piattaforma di Rakuten Viki, una buona parte dei commenti degli utenti erano insulti al suo personaggio. In verità, anche Min Yuk si è preso la sua buona dose di (meritati) insulti, e perfino Yoo Jung, giudicata troppo arrendevole e votata all’inutile sacrificio.
Insomma, ci troviamo di fronte ad un drammone, un vero e proprio melodramma vecchio stampo, prono all’esagerazione, che occorre guardare dimenticando, almeno a tratti, l’esistenza delle parole ‘logica’ e ‘plausibilità’. A parte la massa delle miserie che capitano alla povera Yoo Jung, che manco a Candy Candy, si potrebbe legittimamente chiedersi come, in una grossa società, ad un avvocato appena arrivato vengano affidate posizioni di potere. Le scelte di Se Yeon sono abbastanza estreme e spesso incomprensibilmente autolesionistiche. Il rapporto della coppia principale (Min Yuk e Yoo Jung) è tossico e si sviluppa in maniera morbosa: lui la perseguita ossessivamente ed è almeno concausa di parte delle tragedie che la colpiscono ma, in seguito, pare vittima di una specie di sindrome di Stoccolma al contrario per cui la sua ossessione dall’odio passa all’amore. E questo, nel suo personaggio, potrebbe anche essere comprensibile: la bella ha domato la bestia. Ma la bella, dopo aver subito infinite angherie, tra l’altro completamente immeritate, come può così velocemente innamorarsi della bestia? Diciamo che fa parte del suo carattere.
Tutto ciò, però, potrebbe essere superabile. Se riesce l’operazione mentale ‘segui la storia senza farti troppe domande’, Secret è un drama emotivamente intenso, dove la tensione rimane alta, senza troppi cedimenti, per tutta la durata dell’opera. Forse il finale è stato un po’ affrettato, ma comunque le vicende terminano in modo soddisfacente, alcuni cattivi vengono puniti, altri la fanno franca, ma il mondo sappiamo che non è perfetto.
Ci sono però almeno due punti che potrebbero essere controversi. Il primo riguarda ( SPOILER ) un’adozione irregolare. Lascio il giudizio allo spettatore.
Il secondo, veramente fastidioso, è il vizio che hanno sia Min Yuk che Do Hoon di strattonare e trascinare Yoo Jung qua e là per un braccio. Chiaro che è una scelta registica, d’accordo che siamo in Corea, nel 2013, però è veramente irritante vedere un uomo trattare in questo modo una ragazza, come se fosse una cosa normale. Qualcuno potrebbe dire che a farlo sono i due personaggi figli di buona gatta, e che questa caratteristica aggiunge al loro essere negativi (e infatti verso la fine Min Yuk non lo fa più), ma è sgradevole ugualmente. Tra l’altro, ogni tanto volano anche schiaffi, senza badare troppo al genere di chi li tira e di chi li piglia, tanti che non ne vedevo così dai tempi dei fotoromanzi.
Per rifarci la bocca, possiamo affidarci alla buona colonna sonora: Incurable Disease, Tears Stole the Heart di Ailee, Heights of Wind Storm di Ji Sung hanno certamente costituito un valore aggiunto alla serie, così come la splendida cinematografia, ricca di scene visivamente appaganti e inquadrature particolari.
Insomma, forse bisognerebbe smettere di fare le pulci ai drama, come se fosse divertente dissezionarli scena per scena per trovarvi difetti. E’ vero, Secret è un drama forse antiquato, vagamente imperfetto, con alcuni punti deboli e trama non sempre logica. Ma la carica emotiva trasmessa dal trio principale, nel bene e nel male, è un potente collante che costringe lo spettatore a saltare compulsivamente dalla sigla di coda di un episodio a quella d’inizio del successivo fino a quando, arrivati all’ending del sedicesimo, non ci si rende conto quasi con sgomento che non ci sarà un’altra puntata da vedere. Per la sottoscritta, questo è l’inizio di una potente crisi di astinenza, che cercherà di placare andando a cercare un’altra serie interpretata da Ji Sung. Prima o poi le finirò, e già la cosa mi rattrista.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Promising start, and a steep decline
Good lord, what did I just watch.It feels like I bit into an lush looking apple and tasted the rot inside.
I don't want to waste my time and everyone else's by talking too much about this show. Here's the dealbreaker for this show: sexual assault passed off as romance.
The male lead forcefully kisses the female lead, tortures her mentally, gaslights her, controls her actions, and is in general a downright menace and an antagonist.
I watched as many as 12 episodes because I really thought he was the antagonist and would get his comeuppance, or at the very least change drastically and die tragically.
Didn't seem like that anymore, so I dropped it like a hot potato.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Great drama but 2nd leads excessive screen time is overwhelmingly annoying
Very good drama and Ji Sung is absolutely amazing but the second leads really got on my nerves. By the middle of episode 14, I was ready for someone to whack both, Se Yeon and Do Hoon. They were given way too much screen time. It seemed just about equal to the leads which caused me to feel some turbulent emotions. Lots of positive feelings during Min Hyeok and Yoo Jeong’s scenes and then boom, here come the second leads and their terribleness that immediately killed the mood. This up and down happened way too frequently. If not for this, I would’ve rated this drama a 10/10. Also, Min Hyeok’s father’s hair and makeup were terrible and distracting. I couldn’t take him seriously while looking like a Madame Tussaud wax figure. Other than that, I really enjoyed this drama. Ji Sung and Hwan Jung Eum pair up very well. Glad I gave this one a shot.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
I do not usually watch melodramas but I thought I may give Secret a go (because i just finished kill me heal me and I loved the chemistry between the 2 of them) AND I LOVED IT!!! This drama is a culmination of tears, amazing chemistry and unforgettable moments which heavily provokes a substantial amount of sympathy from audiences!
OK LET US BEGIN!
STORY- 10
WOW!!! what a freken story! twists and turns at every corner! Its a confronting awakening to the fact that love as pure may not be existent HOWEVER the 2 mains don't let us down there! This was acting at its best! Clearly because i think i finished about 2 tissue boxes watching this!! It took me on a wild ride that's for sure!!
ACTING- 10
AGAIN WOW! GOD I LOVE JI SUNG X JUNG EUM! PUTS THEM AT THE TOP FOR ME!!! God they are too good as a couple! their chemistry comes so natural! Its like they're a couple in reality (but that is not going to happen because JI SUNG is taken :( )! Even the bad guys did a good job at being bad, obviously because i punch my screen whenever I i saw se yeon and do noon! So the acting was a definite 10
MUSIC-8.5
It was GREAT.....always had the ability to make me cry like a baby! But i docked 1.5 off because it just lost that happy feel...i know it's a sad drama but i just needed a bit of happiness
REWATCH-8.5
I watched this series in a day and a half! It got me hooked and I am certain i will watch it again just because they did such a good job with the chemistry! I love a arrogant, rich man falling for a not so rich, bright girl....its the romance we all hope for :D
Overall-9 :D
Its not quite a 10 because i think what let it down was the fact that it was a bit overly tragic (the ending saved it tho!! )! BUT i loved it :D
SO DO YOU WANT AN ENGAGING STORY WITH FABULOUS ACTING!
THEN WATCH SECRETS!
YOU WILL NOT FORGET IT!!!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
I really like this drama, for me it is one of the bests of all time.
I think my points for story/acting/music/rewatch value/overall is enough to understand it's gorgeousness there is not much to say. If you want to watch this drama, but still has hesitation, forget all of it and watch it.
Okey at the begining, the story was so worrywart(not sure whether is is the rigt word or not I meant so sad and dark)and for some of you it is similar to Nice Guy but it is not. I watched Nice Guy and like it but let's be fair beside the revenge and prison parts they are not even close. When the story goes on, you just forget all of your bitternes and you go with the flow.
I can't even remember when I started to watch it, it was like yesterday for me.
There is nothing to say cast, Bae Su Bin is the bad guy again, but let's give the devil it's due, he made the best of the role. But still don't like him hehe :)
And Ji Sung&Hwang; Jung Eum, I love them so much, they did an amazing work with this drama.
Even musics were slow(I dont like that kind of musics so much), I relly like them too.
Overall it was FANTABULOUS!
Thanks for everyone contributed to this drama.
P.S: I wish there was a special episode, still heartbroken about it :(
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
