Une adaptation qui se laisse regarder...
Il s’agit d’une adaptation que j’attendais… Tout comme la version animée que j’ai regardé lors de sa sortie. Cependant pour cette version « Live », j’avoue avoir traîné des pieds… (Pourquoi ? Car il s’agit d’un manga que j’apprécie beaucoup & que par expérience, je sais que bien souvent les versions « Live » sont décevantes…)Finalement, 1an après sa sortie, je me suis décidée à me lancer ^^. C’est un drama qui se laisse regarder sans réel problème… L’histoire s’arrêtant pour ainsi dire à la partie « Mafuyu & Ritsuka ». (Ce qui facilite la fin du drama… Même s’il y a pas mal de questions en suspens…)
J’avoue avoir eu un peu de mal avec l’acteur interprétant Mafuyu… Pourtant, ses silences & son absence de réaction colle au manga… (Je ne m’explique donc pas cette réticence ^^’)
Pour finir, je dirais qu’il ne s’agit pas d’une mauvaise adaptation mais que je n’ai pas été conquise… Malgré tout, je dois admettre avoir eu un coup de cœur pour la chanson de Mafuyu… Elle représente tellement pour l’histoire… Elle est profonde & tellement empreinte de tristesse… (Elle fait d’ailleurs actuellement partie de ma playlist x’D)
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Comment avoir l'air de souffrir pour délivrer une émotion ? Leçon n°1 de Sanari
Les adaptations de manga en live-action, c'est toujours un pari risqué. Peu importe la force qu'on tente d'y mettre, c'est difficile de se détacher du support original lorsqu'on le connaît - ce qui est mon cas. Et c'est ce qui est arrivé...J'ai apprécié l'image ainsi que l'utilisation de la lumière naturelle. Le choix des acteurs était plutôt bon. Je ne me formalise pas tellement aux visages. Mais pour le reste, c'est le casse-gueule assuré.
Sanari dans le rôle de Mafuyu était mauvais. Tout au long des épisodes, j'avais l'impression de voir le gars souffrir pour transmettre ne serait-ce qu'un soupçon d'émotions. Autant dans le manga Mafuyu est touchant et on ressent une affection énorme pour le personnage, mais ici ? C'est le pire personnage du drama. On voudrait juste lui dire d'arrêter le massacre. Qu'il soit insensible aurait mieux fonctionné.
On peut aussi bouder l'absence évidente de Akihiro et Haruki qui n'ont pas assez de place dans le drama.
L'autre point, c'est la romance. On sait que Mafuyu et Uenoyama finiront ensemble, on l'a compris assez vite. Cependant, la relation est tellement forcée qu'elle perd tout son naturel, sa surprise et sa fluidité. Aucune profondeur, aucun développement. C'est à peine si la surface est effleurée.
Ils ont tourné Given comme on pense un manga/anime et non un live-action. Et c'est la pire chose à faire. Si vous avez lu le manga ou vu la version animée, restez-en là.
En fin de compte, cette adaptation vivra dans l'ombre de son œuvre originale, car incapable de jouir et forger sa propre identité.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Slow and Boring
Okay so this is another JDRAMA disappointment.I watched the trailer and thought okay so be could interfering but I was extremely disappointed by the 3rd episode i was really bored of it and skipped the last episode altogether so I just couldn't take it anymore.
The main actors seemed okay, accept i did find the second ML really depressing and often frustrating to watch.
The relationship between them was awkwardly enforced to say the least, it wasn't necessarily that these didnt have chemistry, the whole reason for liking the second lead was because he was lonely and had a guitar.
Overall : Given for me was not a good drama to watch, it just was slow and lacked potential with the characters and story line.
Any good JDRAMA recommendations welcomed!!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Better off watching the anime
Coming from a person who has watched the anime and read the manga, this adaptation does not do the original story justice. The show was extremely rushed and because of that oftentimes it got confusing, and that's coming from someone who is familiar with the plot. So I can imagine someones whos not familiar with it must feel. Also because of the feeling of it being rushed, it does not allow the watcher to even empathize with the characters. If the episodes were at least 45 minutes each or there were at least 10 episodes I feel that could have made this series so much better. Other than at of course I think the story is so heartwarmingly beautiful, and the characters are memorable.I would only recommend those who are familiar with the given series to watch this.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
For those who think this was good... what's wrong with you??
Honestly, this show was really bad. I don't know how I could sit through the entire thing. The characters seemed interesting but were really just boring. Every time I thought something good might happen or the characters would show ANYTHING, they did not. And the acting was kind of bad as well. Like I've seen the main lead in Kieta Hatsukoi and his acting was good, but here... I think perhaps it was because of the script and direction, not him. I don't know who wrote the script, but that needed improvement, it was so terrible. I would not recommend this show, it felt like a waste of time.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
A good adaptation, for what it's worth
As a fan of the series, I was excited to know they were making a live-action adaptation. What was a little worrisome and disappointing was the fact that there's only six episodes that are supposed to cover everything from the very beginning of the series until right after the live performance. They did cover that, and for the most part they did surprisingly well with it, but there were still fundamental parts missing that made the series feel somewhat incomplete. I don't know why they skimped out on time- maybe it was a budget thing or something else, but I still feel like they could've afforded to flesh it out just a little bit more.That being said, I'll move onto the praise. The music in this series is great, to start off. The characters and the changes made to the characters were great, too - I liked that they switched things around, added and removed a few things to create a somewhat different feel for the series than the manga and anime go/went for. I feel like the actors filled their shoes very well, and I was surprised by how much I loved Haruki, Akihiko, and especially Hiiragi here. The changes made to their characters made me appreciate them even more somehow, and obviously that's a plus.
With what they had, they did well. It also feels like they almost consciously built up a few things to make it possible for a second season to take place at some point in the future. If there IS none, I'm very confused as to why they even chose to start delving into some plot points, but I guess we'll have to wait and see. For now, with what we have in this live-action adaptation of Given, it's good. Worth a watch, definitely. But it had the potential of being even better.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Given? More like "Given UP" ??
Too be honest I've never watch the anime version so I tried to watch the live adaptation from the manga, after watching it , the truth is its disappointing I think the story it still lacking something , something that gives you mystery and deep story or in-depth of the individual characters, and also this bl lacks chemistry of the male leads I like Uenoyama I think he did great and his cool but Mafuyu btw is ummm… lacking the spark of their relationship bet Uenoyama his face is dull until the last episode like wtf his character is slowly crumbling into thin pieces as a episodes really progress. The song is ok but only 1 song??? After all the practice and hard work?? They didn't even give at least show 3 or more songs to satisfy my appetite like what the hell? Hoping for a season 2 for this bec its open ended, really gutted with this bl could have been better.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
9/10 . Was EPIC
would definitely recommend . my only issue is that it's short needs season 2 ASAP to follow on their journeyI didn't expect the live action to be this GOOD.
it avoids romance / not really a focus on it since it's short and all those six episodes fall into Volume 1 of GIVEN the manga
hope they make a season 2 as the whole plot, setting ,actors were chosen carefully as we all can tell on how much they really resemble the characters in the manga , all of this project just feels unique and rememberle
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Soft and Moving
I haven't seen the anime/manga this is based on so my opinion is purely based on only the show and I think I prefer it this way. I'm used to how jdramas are filmed and paced to those who aren't you may not enjoy it as much. But I really liked this drama. I liked the main characters a lot and felt they had good chemistry. The story was also very good and even though I wish it was longer I liked the pacing and how the story slowly unfolds. My only complaint is that for a show focused on music the music wasn't moving. The singing was weird and I wish they made different choices regarding it. But other than that I do recommend others watch it.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Watch it!
I've tried watching the anime but it didn't stick for me, so finding out there's a live version I got really excited. I don't really understand how one could complain or dislike this show. I found it amazing overall, not even one bad thing about it. Got me to tears at one point too in the last episode. This show to me could've even been just the show itself and not taken from the anime. I understand some people love the live version of their favourite anime or manga but honestly this seemed perfect to me. I'd recommend to watch it all and not be too picky, it's a great show to just quickly watch and finish but also be intrigued throughout it all.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
I am bawling my eyes out
A lot of people told me to don't watch this drama since I would be disappointed. Did I listen? No. I didn't watch the anime so I won't have to worry about comparing both of them. I liked it so much and the song is just Chef's kiss! It left a bruise inside my heart since I could feel Mafuyu's emotions. I have a huge crush on Jin so every time Uenoyama is on the screen I literally scream af because I like him so much. At first, I wondered why the story wasn't focused on Uenoyama and Mafuyu, but then I realized that it was a story focused on Mafuyu's path toward healing. The end was endearing especially when they both kissed hehe. The singing part made me bawl my eyes out. I can feel that he really set himself free at that moment. I am proud of you Mafuyu.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Not What I Thought...and that's a good thing.
So I'm cleaning up my bookmark list - removing bookmarks on everything I've watched - and, lo and behold...now here's something I completely forgot about. Hey, why not give it a watch. If it's not something you're liking you could just stop at any old time and just move on. And that's how I stepped into the world of Uenoyama and Mafuyu. Now, lemme add, all I knew about "Given" was what the synopsis said on MyDramaList, and nothing more. Well ...I was not expecting what I got.First off - it is beautiful. Not in a cosmetic, picturesque way, but in an honest true-to-life manner. As with a lot of recent Japanese dramas (and sometimes comedies too) there is an ever present thread of "alone-ness" that runs throughout - whether it's Hira and Kioyi in "Utsukushii Kare" or Aioki in "Kieta Hatsukoi" or even Adachi in "Cherry Magic!", there's always the sense of watching life pass by from the POV of the outsider, always unwilling or unable to just let go and join in. This time, though, we go to some really dark places. Don't let the High School setting that the series opens with fool you (Oh no! Not that again!), "Given" opens up and reaches into your soul. And, I must say, I really liked the journey. From Mafuyu falling asleep in the studio to Kashima (Mafuyu's friend) reacting to him singing at the concert to the first time Mafuyu sings "lalalala" for Uenoyama - nothing is what I expected. Warning: There will be lumps in throats and there will be wet eyes.
"Given" is awesome, the music is perfect and the actors are sooo real that you knida get lost in their world for a moment. The writing is brilliant and the direction is superb. If there is any criticism to be made is that it could've done with either longer (or maybe a couple more) episodes. I really wanted to spend a little more time with these people. Oh, and by the way, even down to Mafuyu's last line is sheer perfection. Highly recommended.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
