Shan Hun Hou Gu Fu Ren Zai Xian Diao Ma
0 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
I endured this because of course “Mi Qi”,
I endured this because of course “Mi Qi”, if there’s a more perfectly cute and beautiful actress I would love to see her, only “Zhang Shan”, “Jade Jia” , “Chen Yayu, “Li Yaya” & “Tian Miaomiao” come close, Mi Qi” is the queen albeit by slim margin.I have only watched only 1 good version of this miracle doctor from the countryside dramas, besides that one the Yu Long/Yang Mie Mie was passable because of the couple’s chemistry.
This version had on romance was boring and I couldn’t figure out if the FL was supposed to have a split personality, if not why couldn’t she figure everything out considering she is supposedly highly intelligent. Oh well no rewatch in the horizon.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Hollywood meets Makjang, a Modern Day Fairytale
Hollywood meets Makjang, a Modern Day Fairytale( which like it or not is what most of us are here for)Moral of this story women shouldn’t be trusted, because of they are emotional. They won’t stick by you through thick and thin, so men have to take the reins, shoulder the burden and be decisive especially when they recognize a woman who is a good long term bet.
Kudos to the writer for writing a strong male lead, without resorting to grabbing and pulling the female lead’s wrist, being low-key mean etc.., he was decisive but a little unsure sometimes, competent, independent, in-shape and managed his emotions well.
Kudos also for a strong female lead, without resorting to the “kind to everyone no matter how bad they treat you” kdrama trope. She stood up for herself but knew when she needed a man’s help, she was fit, feminine, friendly, and most importantly knew her true feminine strength was being inspirational to those around her.
The screenwriter is a good storyteller, and she accepts the reality of who men and women are. The one on one romantic scenes are more on the realistic side. This is more like a Hollywood modern romance than your typical Kdrama romance that is more prevalent.
If you’re here for romance it doesn’t kick off till about episode 25/30.
Lead actress might not cut out for lead roles(caveat, I have to see her in other lead-roles), but for what the script called for maybe she’s a good choice, but I will have to rewatch to decide. Her expression in her head shot is the same she has 80% of the drama, like she’s just going through the motions, but maybe that’s the direction she got.
Because of the acting choices of the director and lead actress at the start of the drama it’s hard to grow empathy for her character, add to that numerous other characters you start lose focus on and leads, which makes the story disjointed. When you get to the end you start to see what the creatives were going for. That creative choice is certainly up for debate. I think a more emotive actress would have built empathy early and I suspect a lot of viewers were lost in the early stages of the drama.
This show is better suited for watching with a lot of fast forwarding.
Overall I think maybe I see where they were going, the two actresses are technically Co-Leads.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Watch at your own risk.
Watch at your own risk.I suspect the screenwriter, director and a few of the lead actors decided to come together and end their careers. The male lead actor for sure must have been in some sort of scandal or the lead actress sucks at selecting projects at least.
And toxic parent of the century goes to 🥁 “Hong Baek Hee” my new favorite bad guy, she even has 5 goons working for her. SML is really clueless and willfully ignorant going to mom for help, he doesn’t deserve FL.
Clueless chairman award goes to 🥁”Choi Jin Bok”, plus I’m fuzzy on what the company actually does..
The true stars of this drama are the secretaries, and the chairman’s cook/house-lady.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
IU shines.
I have rewatched this twice and it each time the same issues prevent me from rating it higher.1)The unnecessary lack of communication between characters, even within the FL’s family that the writer portrayed as close.
2)Not enough focus on the ML and FL was a missed opportunity, this one aspect prevented this from being regarded as one of KDrama’s best shows. Because if you look at some of the best all time favorites, like my love from the stars, crash landing, descendants of the sun, it’s ok not to not be okay , flower of evil, extraordinary attorney, queen of tears, alchemy, and on, and on….
Only “Slice Of Life” dramas with strong cast’s can pull off spreading out the focus.
That being said I recommend this because IU’s performance and it factor is a thing of beauty to watch.
And in my opinion this is one Yoo In Na and Jo Jung Suk’s best performances.
Also this show had the most ‘Legs’ of any show I’ve seen, I wonder if the director had a thing?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
I Wanted To Like It.
Where do I start,1) Worst ML casting I’ve ever seen, is he really an actor? Or was this a parachute hire? Did he detest “Seol In Ah” in real life? Did she detest him? I don’t know what happened but ML and FL had negative chemistry, I suspect the script was changed to reduce their interactions. Whatever it was it ruined the show.
2) I wanted to like this because of Seol In Ah, but because of what I mentioned above her role was cut back, even the main plot line didn’t involve her and male lead till the last 2 episodes, and it was minimal. In the last few episodes the inevitable scene where ML has to comfort FL was awkward at best and cringe worthy, she reluctantly let him give her the worst consoling hug I’ve ever seen on screen.
3) Resolving the main plot point didn’t happen until the last 5 episodes or so, and I suspect that had something to do with the ML & FL problem and rewriting the script.
I could never rewatch this, if you like Seol In Ah, watch Business Proposal or Twinkling Watermelon.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Seol Hyun Shines
It took me 1 1/2 years to complete this drama, because1)Slow beginning
2)Fl’s drunk episode
3)ML mumbling
4)FL started out a tad bit unlikeable
But once I got past episode (6) it’s actually a decent drama.
No other actress could have pulled off the leading lady role, Seol Hyun’s fresh faced beauty, her flowing locks, her infectious smile…. I put her in the top (5) of all Korean Actresses.
The other actors all did a good job.
Bom grows on you over time, the other characters have decent growth arcs.
***Slight Spoiler Warning***
The antagonists, there’s more than one are well written and surprising.
I would have given this a higher rating if not for the use of the ubiquitous KDrama “drunken plot device”
Please KDrama use this a bit more judiciously, I employ you.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Skip to episode 11
Story idea/concept (8)The idea is not groundbreaking, but the shopping concept is interesting.
Script (5)
The writer for some unfathomable reason stretched out the setup over 10 episodes, and then had to hurriedly wrap up the show.
Directing (8)
Was ok
Pacing (7)
Was weakened by the script writers choices
Acting (8)
Male lead always has the same facial expressions in every show I’ve seen him in, with limited range, but the other actors carried the drama.
Wardrobe (8)
Was well done and ok overall.
Sets/Locations (8)
Typical of Kdramas, thank goodness the product placement was not irritating as they can sometimes be in Kdramas
Skip to episode 11, in my opinion that’s when the show finally finds direction. Everything that happens prior is rehashed in subsequent episodes anyway so you don’t really miss much, because the male lead is highly irritating in the early episodes.
Episodes 1 to 10 should have been covered in 3 episodes, episodes 11 to 16 should have been spread out to 13 episodes.
Rewatch Value (2)
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Convoluted Mess
Menu= Concept/Outline ~(10)Ingredients/Recipe= Script/Writer ~(4)
Chef= Director/Pacing/Editing ~(5)
Flavor/Taste= Actors/Performances ~(8)
Restaurant/Decor= Wardrobe/Production-Value ~(3)
Waiter/Service= Cinematography ~(9)
Starter/1st Act ~(10)
Main Course /2nd Act ~(7)
Dessert/3rd Act ~(2)
The story idea is great, but the script was convoluted, it started out great but spiraled into a schizophrenic mess. The ML’s character was portrayed childish in an effort to force forcefully inject comedy/humor into the show, I think humor/comedy through dialogue beats slapstick situations any day.
Because of the childishness and incompetence of ML’s character the romance was unbelievable, forced with little chemistry.
The FL’s character was great and required a competent assertive ML to make her growth arc believable, e.g. “taming of the shrew”.
The wardrobe as a tool to convey each character’s personality was used half heartedly with everyone expect the main leads.
The ML’s wardrobe was childish from start to finish and in no way vibed with the FL’s.
The directing was good, but with a weak script? Well….
1st act was actually riveting and had me glued to the screen, but by the 2nd act you couldn’t tell what the drama was supposed to be. By the 3rd act you could tell the show didn’t know how to wrap things up.
Romance fell flat.
Intrigue was nonexistent.
Humor yeah right.
What are rules for Angels in this drama’s world? Even the characters didn’t know let alone the audience.
The main antagonist was clearly halfheartedly put in by the writer, evidenced by the lack of a clear motivation. It seemed like someone reminded the writer to add villain half into the script.
Finally the breakups, smh, to many and unnecessarily so and all using the same stupid justification trope!!!
I don’t understand the high rating for this show.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Pure and wonderful escapism.
Menu= Synopsis/Concept ~(8)Ingredients/Recipes= Script Writer ~(9)
Chef= Director ~(9)
Flavors/Taste= Actors/Performances ~(10)
Restaurant/Decor= Wardrobe Production-Value ~(10)
Waiter/Service= Editing/Cinematography ~(10)
Starter/1st Act ~(9)
Main Course /2nd Act ~(10)
Dessert/3rd Act ~(8)
Pure escapism, warm and fuzzy. The lead actress where beautiful coupled with great acting.
I personally prefer simple straightforward storytelling, injecting over the top conflict for conflict’s sake is overrated.
Talking pictures are for unwinding after dealing with reality.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Nian Nian Bu Wang Ai You Hui Xiang
0 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Legitimately The Funniest Drama
This is legitimately the funniest drama I have ever watched, that includes K-Drama & Hollywood, and thank goodness there was no slapstick humor as is invariably the case,I suspect Zhang Zi Lin improved some of her lines, she carried this drama on her beautiful delicate back. Bravo young lady or should I say Xiǎojiě / 小姐
The story was also very well written and acted.
A great rewatch.
These are some of her funniest lines below.
***SPOILER BELOW***
She told SFL about breaking engagement- “ you picked up a sesame seed and threw away a watermelon”
After sneaking to check ML's morning erection "I probably should be paying to look at this"
She told a SFL- “I chose you because you’re brainless instead my sister who is evil”
She told evil aunt- “A lot of people around your age are dead, why are you still alive? Are you immortal?”
Another good line "As long as I have no morals, no one else can kidnap me with morality"
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Chong Sheng Hou Wo Cheng Le Pian Zhi Da Lao Di Yao Yin
0 pessoas acharam esta resenha útil
One Of The Best Vertical Dramas Made To Date.
This is one of the best vertical dramas made to date.Rebirth & revenge, no prisoners taken, no excess saliva and protracted bullying scenes, best enemies to lovers.
And it's a rebirth/revenge that actually has decent romance
It had alot of the standard tropes, mall shopping bullying, radom bullying, jealous exgirlfriend and stepsister, severing family-ties, spiking drink, framing, and the inevitable kidnapping, but what made this stand out was how it was all handled, all the bad guys got retribution swiftly and appropriately, even some lost their lives and it had the appropriate amount of blood spilled to satisfy viewers.
No antagonist was allowed to hang around unnecessarily, ML clearly & swiftly rejected all green tea females, and they were not allowed to linger irritatingly.
Even when the ML nanny was bullied the resolution was satisfying.
Yao Yu Chen's smile is he icing on cake and Zhou Hang played the most masculine character I've ever seen.
Great rewatch, I’m adding this drama to my all time favorite list along side dramas like, My Love From The Stars, Five Enough, Moving, The Man From Nowhere, Healer, Etc….
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Park Shin Hye, a star is born.
Park Shin Hye was the lead through and through.The story was well written, it maybe should have had an extra episode to punctuate the lead’s romance, but I suspect they didn’t want to show a pregnancy wrap up episode as per usual in these kind of dramas because of the lead actress’s age.
The brightest spot in view is the decent balance of toxic to positive characters, this increases the rewatch value. The usual crazy, loud, self awareness lacking characters where kept to a minimum.
The other main where also given adequate screen time and arcs. The elder characters were surprisingly not 1 dimensionally portrayed like they are sometimes are.
Most off the plot points are realistic. Most males would fall for a female who is inexperienced, positive, upbeat, untouched and easy to be around if they are in close proximity to her.
I highly recommend this one for those that like traditional romance.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
A train wreck
This show is quite stupid. It seems to have been written by 10th graders, or maybe it’s an April Fool’s joke on the viewers??Abandon medical school to be a pastry chef?? You don’t see him in making pastries??
Low effort from the production team, the lead actors etc..
And it commits the worst crime of all by being boring.
On the surface it seems like a normal show, it’s like sticking your hand in a bag of donuts only to pull out your hand and it’s covered in dog p@@p.
Start watching at your own risk, you’ve gotten a fair warning, so you have no one to blame but yourself.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Script Writer (10)
Director (9)
Actors/Performances (10+)
Wardrobe Production-Value (10+)
Editing/Cinematography (9)
1st Act (10)
2nd Act (10+)
3rd Act (9)
The Script/Synopsis/Concept is not exactly mind blowing, but the writer and director were able to flesh it out and mould the show into a memorable drama.
Non of the lost memories, time jump, yelling Ajummas, switched at birth, drunkenness, giving all your money to family members, subservient women, weak/feminine men, and other quirky Kdrama tropes.
The acting was great especially the female lead, she portrayed happy, sad, jealousy, anger, suspicion, crazy, so mart, decisive, friction with mom, loving nonna, and so on. It must have been a dream role for the actress.
Every actor & character got there moments to shine, all the main actors are stars in their own respective.The wardrobe was iconic and timeless, the main set (ML’s home) was so good it was an even a tourist attraction in Seoul.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?