An Enjoyable Watch
【Ｓｔｏｒｙ】6.5The premise of this drama is fun and exciting. Though I find the implementation of that premise to be a mixed bag. Over all broad view it's a great story, with a lot of excitement. I really like the story beats, as well as the twists and turns the story takes.
Sadly, the path to to these story beats is marred by the writing. This drama heavily relies on character emotion to drive the story forward. But, it uses this tool like blunt weapon with no grace. Characters will often do something irrational, with no plan or purpose behind their actions, using emotion as an excuse. This is hard to explain without spoiling anything, but the best example of this comes as soon as episode 2, between the male lead and the female lead, and continues throughout the show.
【Ａｃｔｉｎｇ／Ｃａｓｔ】9
I absolutely adore the cast in this drama. Every casting choice feels spot on and everyone really embodies their roles.
I'm knocking off a point for Park Hwan Hee crying scenes. They just feel uncomfortable because of the bad fake crying.
【Ｍｕｓｉｃ】10
Nothing much to say about the music. It is used when it is appropriate and the music fits the scenes.
【Ｒｅｗａｔｃｈ Ｖａｌｕｅ】3
Once you have watched it once, I don't think you will get anything new from a rewatch. I also don't think it would be all that enjoyable once you know the story twists.
【Ｏｖｅｒａｌｌ】7
It is an enjoyable watch, but don't expect it to be life changing. If you are like me you will enjoy your time watching this show, but will also be annoyed with the way every most actions seem to have no real rational behind them.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Human x Robot story with fluffy romance
Positives: Overall a nice drama with cute romance, funny moments and schemes. It has nice visuals.Personal negatives: The story started strongly, but became less interesting over time, it wasn't too deep and didn't delve much into the problem of existence of robots. It is more for people who want something where you don't have to think too hard (not for me).
The drama had a promising start, the story was interesting. What didn't make sense to me was how the mother could leave her child so easily, there were also other absurd things further in the story.
I liked when So Bong didn't know Nam Sin III was a robot and I wish this tense relationship would last a little bit longer. After So Bong figured it out and started liking him, it became too fluffy for me. I would also appreciate more physical romance, I really missed more passion - we got many hugs, but only few kisses. I guess they thought that viewers could feel weird about it, when he is a robot. They could have just gone for it though, when its human x robot romance, and the robot is supposed to be a thinking creature.
Not all of the characters were well written. Despite all the things he has done, Jong Gil didn't feel too evil, I actually resented Nam Sin's mom more. So Bong was strong, but too bland and her father was that classic parent we often see in comedies, I do not like these kinds of characters because the comedy feels too forced.
Many problems of Nam Shin III being a robot were left shallow, when other people found out he was robot, they were shocked at first, but accepted him quite quickly. The people didn't question his feelings that much.
The classic fighting over who gets the company, was a bit boring. Especially the last few episodes, that were filled with it felt slow. I wish they would wrap it up sooner. The ending itself was predictable, they never convinced me, that Nam Sin III was dead for good. I was also upset, that it was never revealed that Nam Sin's dad didn't just fall to his death, but that he was killed by Jong Gil.
The actors did quite a good job. Notably Seo Kang Joons acting was very good. In the beginning I couldn't even believe that the two characters were played by one actor, like even their facial features seemed a bit different - robot Nam Sins face looked softer, like can he shapeshift? :D Maybe it was because of the different hair style, I guess the stylists did a good job. Anyway, you could really tell which character was on the screen if you just saw him walk. I also liked Lee Joon Hyuk, his character seemed a bit mysterious and I was rooting for his friendship with robot Nam Shin.
As a Czech person, I enjoyed the appearence of Czech Republic (even if it was sadly only in the first episode), I assume they choose it because Czechs coined the word robot. I have to say Kang Joons Czech was quite good. But it was also funny hearing Koreans pronounce Czech words. I don't know if it was intentional, but the robot Nam Sins pronounciation seemed better than the human Nam Sins, who didn't grow up there.
The music was OK, I liked one OST, but other than that nothing was too memorable. The special effect were really good, like his robot parts, when he got hurt, fit in nicely and didn't look weird, I also liked how his eyes changed.
I actually enjoyed the drama up to like 12 episodes, but I slowly started to loose interest. I am being quite critical above, I am just stating what I noticed (because I think a lot), but it was a nice drama overall.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
This show is incredible. I’ve never been much interested in sci-fi dramas and came across this one totally by chance. But now, I'm really thankful to god that I encountered such a masterpiece! I binge watched the series and absolutely loved it.'Are you human too?' is a show that will leave you awestruck after each and every episode! The plot is perfect, story is perfect, cast is perfect and cinematic experience is so amazing! Seo Kang joon's acting is absolutely mind boggling, his ability to portray two very contrasting characters had me stunned more than once throughout the drama. In certain scenes where it’s quite impossible not to show human emotions, he maintains his robotic persona without fault. He’s so extremely lovable in one scene and as soon as his second character comes on the screen, you feel this undeniable hate.
I could relate to both Nam Shin 3 and Nam Shin as both were correct in their respective places. You'd despise the human Nam Shin and his psychopathic behavior but just think once, what does it feels like to loose your everything to a complete stranger? We've grown up watching movies that show how machines and robots could turn into evil and harm mankind. But what if it's the other way around? This drama shows how the creators can become their own destroyers over greed and ego. Presenting this angstful side of human nature just brought life to the whole drama and made it one of its kind.
Lee Joon Hyuk is a special mention here as he pulls off his role amazingly and makes the entire plot so thrilling. Also, I really felt that the connections between the male and female leads were so heartwarming. Be it his mother or his bodygaurd, the relations were pure and full of unconditional love.
This show hit me hard because it's way different from the old school love between human and robot.(as if it's possible you may say xD). Since this is a fictional sci-fi drama, you can not expect everything to be realistic. At some point you may feel that things are going overboard, but my only suggestion to you would be: ignore the little mistakes, watch it as a fantasy drama and keep your realistic logics aside for a while. This way, You’ll definitely enjoy this fun filled drama.
Moreover, I don't know who categorised this under pure romance genre as to me it seemed more of a political thriller and mystery drama. Bits of romance and comedy in between are just cherry on the top of the cake. The story includes so many things at the same time, that it'll leave you longing for more episode after episode. As the story unfolds, you get to dig deeper into the roots of hidden secrets.
VERIDCT: If you want to experience love, friendship, happiness, heartbreak, honesty, rivalry, politics, mystery and all sort of emotions at one place, this show is a MUST WATCH!
PS: OST of the drama is just heavenly and blends well with the scenes. It drowned me so much that i'm listening to it on repeat on Spotify right now
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Had low expectations for this drama but was pleasantly surprised. It's my first time watching Seo Kang Joon and I was very impressed by his performance. Acting out duel roles can be very tricky and hard to execute properly, and I thought he did an excellent job to the point where I could have mistaken him for 2 separate actors. He nearly impressed me as much as Yeo Jin-Goo in The Crowned Clown (although that show still takes the cake for Top 5). I was hoping the sci-fi factor would veer a litttttle bit into fantasy by somehow giving him true chemical emotions and sensation near the end. I was craving a good cry out of Nam-Shin III or a reaction out of pain, but the emotional depth he was able to show near the end was very satisfying. I really liked the FL and Young Hoon. Their chemistry with both Shins was palpable (in platonic, romantic, and angry scenes). It was interesting to see how the dynamic between both Shins and the FL and Young Hoon changed throughout the show.
Overall, I don't know if I'd watch this show again, but I think it's worth the watch nonetheless.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Wonderful watch
I really enjoyed this series. It's a very interesting plot that makes you contemplate what it means to be human and at what point would you start seeing/treating AI as such. Also what place they could possibly hold in society.Thsi was also my first introduction into Seo Kang Joon. He played Nam Shin 3 with such innocense and heart that you really start to feel for him, even though he is 'just' an AI robot.
First I was worried for the ending, because K-drama's usually have 'realistic' ending where regular westerns shows mostly have a romantic ending. It was realistic, but still enough to satisfy the romantic in me. Absolutely worth a (re)watch.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
This is PEEEERFECT let me tell you why...
I may be exaggerating but this drama deserve a spot in my top 5 kdrama list of all time!!STORY- Yes I love the plot/storyline. At first I really wondered how this will work out between a robot and human and some may find it weird and criticize the series before they even watch after reading the synopsis and would even hope for the real Human Nam Shin to end up with So Bong and will be left disappointed. However, this series will prove them wrong, because who would hate an adorable robot like Nam Shin III, right? The cast didn't overact and I love how every characters in the story played their part. Especially Ye Na I sooo much appreciate her, she contributed a lot in the movie where she would do everything to help Nam Shin even though he doesn't love her ( which I hoped for them two to end up together but it will be weird to have the a boyfriend with the same face as Nam Shin III)
ACTING- Hats Off to all cast for their superb acting, Korea has a standard in acting and so does here in Philippines and almost all characters in korea are really versatile even cameos are doing a goodjob. Though I still see some korean actors/actresses that is a little bit over when it comes to their acting capabilities once in a while, would stare too much and is really unrealistic I would cringe. In this series Seung Yeon and Kang Joon really have a good chemistry here and I love how Kang Joon did a good Job portraying the Robot Nam Shin.
MUSIC- Yes of course, i love their OST 'Is it love'. I already have it on loop hahahhaha
REWATCH- Don't me hahaha I watched this THRICEEE! I can even tell you the details of each episode here :D
THIS IS A MUST WATCH!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Pour qu'un homme soit parfait, il faut qu'ils soit une A.I...
Avec un scénario complètement barré, et parfois vraiment écrit avec les pieds, je me suis pourtant trouvée scotchée devant mon écran durant les 18 épisodes du drama! Pourquoi ??? Parce que les acteurs ont vraiment donné vie à cette histoire improbable, et particulièrement Seo Kang Joon, vraiment parfait dans un double rôle assez piégeux !Le scénario est bâclé au niveau de la logique des déplacements, de l’enchaînement des évènements, on se dit souvent « comment il est arrivé là ? » ou « d’où il a sorti cette moto, avec casque et équipements ? » ou « Qui a tout nettoyé, et comment ? » On sent que le scénariste n’en a strictement rien à faire, de ce côté technique de l’histoire, car son seul intérêt, c’est d’abord la personnalité du robot, qui va évoluer, se former et s’affirmer au fil de ce qu’on lui demande de faire, de qui il rencontre sans jamais perdre de vue qu’il ne sera jamais humain, comme il le dit : je comprends les émotions mais je ne les ressens pas.
Ensuite, c’est l’affrontement de l’AI et de l’humain qui lui a servi de modèle. Là, c’est très intéressant de voir l’effet de cette rencontre à la fois sur une personnalité qu’une enfance difficile a rendue instable, en quête de reconnaissance, et sur son double parfait qui va acquérir aussi maturité et capacité de jugement au fil des évènements.
Ce face-face est le vrai cœur du drama, soutenu par des intrigues de palais dans la société, et par la romance entre Nam Shin III et Kang So Bong, sa garde du corps. Cette romance échappe au ridicule grâce au caractère bien trempé de So Bong, et au soin qu’ont pris les scénaristes de ne jamais laisser oublier que le robot n’éprouve pas de sentiments. Il ne peut être amoureux, mais il devient capable de ressentir qu’une personne est là pour lui et l’aide, et le connaît tel qu’il est. C’est cette prise de conscience qui servira de base à la relation avec So Bong,se renforçant de plus en plus.
Il y a quelques sommets dans la première partie, avant la confrontation des deux, comme l’incendie, ou l’accident de la voiture autonome… La seconde partie est plus psychologique, mais pour moi la plus intéressante.
Toute l’histoire est aussi sous-tendue par le thème : l’AI peut-elle donner des robot avec une telle possibilité d’évolution et d’adaptation qu’ils en deviendraient presque humains ? Et alors où s’arrêterait le fait d’être humain ? Bon, le robot, ici, donne une image hyper positive de l’AI ! On pourrait réécrire l’histoire est le faisant devenir un danger car c’est toujours une machine, et tout dépend de qui et comment on l’utilise ! Nam Shin III va peu à peu se créer une morale, en plus de l’éthique que lui a donnée sa créatrice, la loi d’Isaac Asimov : « ne pas nuire aux humains ».
Je reviens sur Seo Kang Joon, il est parfait ! En passant, compliments aux maquilleurs et aux techniciens du numérique qui réussissent à faire oublier quelques instant qu’il n’y a qu’un acteur ! Le travail sur le visage du robot est parfait, modifiant juste ce qu’il faut l’aspect de la peau. Le recours au numérique donne un éclat particulier aux yeux de Seo Kang Joon, accentuant leur couleur brun clair (la même que celle des yeux de So Bong, d’ailleurs, c’est amusant !) et l’acteur ajoute son talent donnant les expressions différentes(le sourire, le port de la tête, …)
Autre personnage très intéressant et même intrigant : Ji Young Moon, l’assistant de Shin, celui qui prenait les coups à sa place, celui qui le sort des mauvais pas. Il y a plus qu’une relation amicale entre eux, par moment j’ai pensé qu’il y avait de l’amour du côté de Young Hoon. D’ailleurs il refuse toujours de définir sa relation quand Shin III lui pose la question… j’aurais bien aimé qu’il y réponde, car ça aurait rajouté un plus au drama, au niveau de la psychologie des personnages s’il y avait eu là un autre amour sens unique… L’acteur Lee Joon Hyuk, que j’avais repéré dans les 2 Stranger, est vraiment très bien, tout en maîtrise avec par moment, des fêlures mélancoliques …
parlons de la fin ! Eh bien je l’aurais préférée moins guimauve, parce qu’enfin ! C’est un robot ! Alors que le scénariste insiste bien tout du long sur cet aspect, là ça finit sur le classique « je reste avec toi pour la vie » et quand même il y a des aspects de la vie qu’un robot ne peut pas assumer (les enfants, par exemple..) Il y aurait eu une fin plus belle sans les 10 dernières minutes, que So Bong ait une chance de garder un merveilleux souvenir, puis de vivre une vraie vie de femme !
Malgré tout j’ai eu du plaisir à cette dernière scène, et aux quelques phrases échangées entre le père de Shin III, le vrai Shin et Jin Young Hoon qui laissent entrevoir un avenir meilleur pour les trois…
Oui, c’est contradictoire, mais c’est comme ça ! ^_^
J’ai vu que Seo Kang Joon chante une chanson dans le drama, j’ai voulu écouter et le moins que je puisse dire c’est qu’il vaut mieux qu’il soit acteur le plus possible ! ^_^
Au total un drama qui nous saisit et nous emporte en nous faisant oublier tous les défauts de scénarios par la grâce des yeux d’or de Seo Kang Joon !
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
A ride more rollicking dan I imagined !!
DRAMATIC & FANTASTICLY executed kdrama wid human-robo romance !! Abt a robot wid a "heart" as he experiences life & grows into a "human." Seeing him as he longs 2 b accepted 4 wat he is,was so touching to watch.INTRESTING PLOT ==TIN-CAN COUPLE==ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ==LOVE OF A MOTHER==OST==CHINGU
//VERDICT// Not gonna lie; I was a little sad 2 get 2 de end of dis show as I found myself having a pretty good time. To me, best of all was the fact that show understood its main appeal & remembered 2 keep on giving Namshin opportunities 2 keep on growing more & more independent & human-like & time 2 demonstrate dat he does have feelings, even if it’s against his operating system.
P.S Seo Kang Joon is absolutely fantastic in this, demonstrating acting chops dat I never knew he had. Show is worth the watch just to see him in action.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
« Are You Human Too ? » est un drama que j’ai beaucoup apprécié, malgré ses points faibles. Une histoire de base unique, intéressante, avec le côté robotique qui ajoute sa touche d’originalité, avec des acteurs doués, surtout Seo Kang Joon, l’acteur principal qui a su performer à merveille dans ses rôles, autant celui d’humain, que dans sa version robot. Ce drama se concentre davantage sur les personnages. Il y a des points faibles, (...) mais les points forts (le talent de Seo Kang Joon dans ces deux rôles si différents) et la romance si belle et mignonne qui ne manque pas de faire sourire, font de « Are You Human Too ? » un drama que je recommande avec plaisir !
°~°~°~°~°~°~°~°~°~°~°
Avis Complet:
https://lamagiedeshistoires.wordpress.com/2024/02/19/are-you-human-too-avis/
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
I want that robot
I absolutely loved this drama, every episode. All of them... but the last two. The ending is forced. Illogical things happen and almost random events allow the plot to move forward. A bit 'a mess, in short. So my note and my review go from ep 1 to ep 17 beginning. The summary is: this robot is drop dead gorgeous. I was also passionate about the plot. The relationship between the robot and the girl is adorable and the chemistry between the two is sparkling. The evolution of the humanity of the robot is told really well. Unfortunately, there are a few X-rated issues that remain unexplained and that make me question the success of their eternal love, but whatever, let's pretend everything is perfect there too. Besides, they are so cute!Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The Feels
Idk how I ended up here, but I'm so glad I did! Anyway, if you can get past the "I'm a human who loves a robot" theme this is actually an amazing drama. In classic K-Drama style, there's fluffy romance and plenty of plot twists that all come crashing down in the juiciest way! If you don't wanna upper cut the MC into another dimension through 99.9% of this drama you're definitely a robot lol Seo Kang Joon/Nam Shin does the split personality vibe flawlessly, which made this series an even bigger emotional roller coaster slam packed with high blood pressure and family issues lmaoHighly recommend if you want something romantic with even amounts of chaos
100/10 for the ending
Enjoy...
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
In my opinion
The plot was very nice, I found the plot fresh and unique. I cannot say the acting was believable but sometimes a bit too much. The main actor pulled off the two characters very well and the actress who play the main's actor mom shone for the minor screentime she got. The show's effects were very cringey too me and I sometimes found myself laughing at the way the male lead tried to pull off the effects. The love line seemed a bit unnatural, I mean it is between a robot and a human but that's not the unusual part the buildup of the love line seemed a little bit flaccid. I had a bit of a struggle watching this drama, but others may think otherwise. Overall, you can watch this show if you please, it's just now worthy of a rewatch though.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
