Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Drama avec maladie incurable, pleurs et émotions assurés...et ennui !
J'ai fini Uncotrallably fond, et je suis très partagée sur ce drama.Le début (premier épisode) m'a emballée : rapide, clair, précis, j'ai accroché de suite... mais ensuite j'ai été déstabilisée par des flash back assez brouillons, trop longs (on perdait de vue le présent pendant trop longtemps) qui me faisaient me demander à quelle époque on était, surtout qu'il y a trois étapes : l'école, quelques années après et le présent... certains personnages arrivaient sans qu'on sache d'où ils sortaient ou qui ils étaient et pourquoi ils agissaient comme ça... Bref, j'ai eu un peu de mal avec ça. Ensuite l'attitude de Joon Young envers No Eul était assez incohérente :
Spoiler:
après s'être décarcassé pour qu'elle croie en son amour, il vire bord sur bord, la fait affreusement souffrir par une froideur totalement inexplicable (pour elle et pour moi aussi au début) uniquement parce que Ji Tae lui dit qu'il n'a pas le droit de l'aimer, et lui non plus ce qui ne l'empêche pas de continuer à la suivre partout tout en la rejetant...
Bref, ça manquait de cohérence, à mes yeux, et les explications étaient peu claires, arrivant au compte-goutte avec pour moi une sensation d'écriture brouillonne plutôt que de suspense bien conduit. En fait j'ai failli laisser tomber et j'avoue avoir sauté un épisode entier, le 17 et ça ne m'a pas du tout gênée pour la suite ! je n'en pouvais plus de voir No Eul essayer de comprendre Joon Young !
Alors pourquoi continuer ? Eh bien pour les deux personnages principaux : No Eul n'est pas l'héroïne bêlante et stéréotypée habituelle mais une femme dure, cynique, qui ne s'en laisse pas compter,
Spoiler:
et son attitude envers l'argent, inhabituelle, est réaliste même si j'ai été contente de voir à la toute fin qu'elle n'en est plus là et peut enfin se permettre d'avoir une conscience. Oui, c'est dur de refuser un gros pot de vin quand on a les sbires des usuriers aux fesses !!
Cependant, si le personnage m'a beaucoup intéressée, Bae Suzy m'a moins convaincue, forçant trop sur le côté un peu braillard que la langue coréenne peut avoir surtout quand c'est utilisé constamment sur le même ton, ça devient lassant.
Mais celui qui porte le drama, à mes yeux, et qui est absolument remarquable c'est bien sûr Kim Woo Bin !!
Quelle présence ! quelle maîtrise des silences ! Son sourire est l'apparition d'une lumière, les scènes avec sa mère
Spoiler:
(encore une mère coréenne incompréhensible et détestable, au moins pendant les 3/4 du drama, et encore ! Elle sait son fils mourant et elle ne va pas le voir !!! )
sont toujours touchantes, et quand il subit les attaques de sa maladie.
Le truc du drama avec maladie incurable a été et sera abondamment exploité, du fait de toutes les possibilités mélodramatiques que ça implique, ici l'originalité vient du fait que c'est su d'entrée de jeu, que Joon Young ne veut pas mettre les pieds à l'hôpital, ce qui évite les scènes habituelles du genre. Le talent de Kim Woo Bin
Spoiler:
pour nous faire partager ses émotions, quand il est confronté à des remarques sur la mort, lui qui sait ce qui l'attend, est remarquable. La scène où Ji-Tae a le culot de lui dire d'aller mourir en paix et de ne plus s'occuper de rien, son silence son regard, sont poignants.
Alors, cahin-caha je suis donc arrivée à l'épisode 18 et là je dois dire que les trois derniers épisodes sont parfaits, d'une part parce qu'enfin les choses bougent
Spoiler:
entre Joon Young et son père, la découverte de sa maladie, son attitude envers la vile morue. La façon dont ses pertes de mémoires sont traitées est bouleversante de simplicité, comme la façon dont No Eul les comprend et les gère. Le sommet a été pour moi la visite de sa mère, qu'il ne reconnaît qu'à sa cuisine, et j'avoue que j'ai pleuré là, parce que cette scène était parfaitement interprétée par les deux acteurs et qu'elle était proprement déchirante ! La façon aussi dont sa mort est traitée, et ensuite de voir comment la vie continue car No Eul n'est pas du genre à se complaire dans le deuil éternel...
Bref, ces trois derniers épisodes, le jeu de Kim Woo Bin (et du reste du casting, d'ailleurs ) ont fait qu'au final je garde une très belle impression du drama, tout en me souvenant que par moment j'ai failli l'abandonner.
Il est à voir, pour Kim Woo Bin, (je vais mettre des cierges pour lui !! ) mais je conseille un peu d'accélération entre les épisodes 14 et 17 !!
Bon, pardon pour ce long commentaire, et pardon aux inconditionnelles du drama si ma critique les a choquées, mais j'ai essayé d'être aussi sincère que possible !
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
SADEST DRAMA EVER!! And Why only 8.0?
Just watch this because of Kim Woo Bin's acting. He is soo good.I knew it was a tearjerker and I thought I could handle it. But it was beyond my reach and will get attached to it even from the first episode. And let me say its because of Kim Woo Bin's acting skills alone. FL was also good and did her best but he steal the show.
Yh it has some dramatic moments that could be avoided but its ok since the drama as a whole packege is good.
The rating is given only 8.0 and I dont know why. It deserves more than 8.0.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
This drama wrecked me. I came in looking for a lighthearted romance. This was so much more.From the very first episode, you would be able to tell that this drama is no joke. It's mature and serious and will pull at your heartstrings.
It is a reminder to give second chances, to cherish those whom you love, to apologize when necessary, to speak up, to tell someone how you feel before it's too late.
While Noh Eul and Joon Young had their ups and downs, they are a prime example of trusting your gut. Don't wait until it's too late.
Joon Young was more than his illness. He was more than his career. He was more than every label he was given. He lived well and on his own terms. I'm glad that he held onto Noh Eul. I'm glad that he didn't give in.
Despite everything, Noh Eul and Joon Young were there for one another. Isn't that ultimately what true love is? In sickness and in health? Through the pain and into new beginnings.
Noh Eul had to go on with life, but Joon Young will be with her every step of the way, counting all the reasons he loves her. From one reason and way past nine and a half and a quarter and an eighth and a sixteenth.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Kim Woo Bin is Amazing and I am here for it
I was on the fence about watching this one considering I am not into melodrama and I generally go for light and breezy stuff. I somehow watched the first two episodes and while the story for me was too intense, I absolutely adored KWB. He is gorgeous and did a great job at being the angsty, sad, conflicted and sometimes cruel person his character is.The story did not make sense at times, many characters made questionable and frustrating choices throughout the drama. However, the main leads worked for me together, their chemistry was great and they had adorable moments together. They were truly star crossed lovers and the actors played their part to perfection (yes, even Suzy).
The OST was beautiful, the cinematography carried the story-telling to some point. The side characters for me were a bit annoying. They lacked a certain depth and showed no significant development by the finale apart from the obvious change of hear that was bound to happen.
Overall, this one is a tear jerker and all those moments of brilliance and emotions belong to Kim Woo Bin, he was exceptional and carried this show on his back.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
I'm depressed
Yes this drama definitely gave me depression. But that's on me cause I knew what I was getting myself into. I just finished the drama and I have to talk about it right fucking now. Yes.. It was a full on emotional ride and I enjoyed every second of it. I mean yes it had it's melodrama but it wasn’t cringe. It never made me cringe. I loved every bit of it. Every character had their own stories. The series was so beautifully made. There were so many connections. Everything just made sense somehow. Now of course you cant look for logics and science from a drama like this. It served it purpose and made me cry. I had to mentally prepare myself for the trauma I'm gonna get from next episode lol. So yes I'd say the series was good.Kim Woo Bin owns my heart. He stole the show. The way he smiled but you could see the pain in his eyes just made the show even better. Istg I just wanted to protect our big baby Jun- Young from everything. He deserves the world. How can a person cry so beautifully please God really took His time creating this man . His smile my goodness. I'll sell myself for that smile.
I can't think of a better partner than Bae Suzy in this series. She's literally so pretty. That couple was the best in my opinion. I don’t say this often for straight couples lol.
Im Joo Hwan.... He has this really beautiful skintone. Unusual features that made him very attractive. I really was hoping him to be with Eul in the last episode. He did a great job with the character. I loved this Ji-Tae character. I wish we could actually see a lil more bromance between Ji-Tae and Jun-Young. They had a really great chemistry lol
All in all I was very satisfied with the cast. Also it broke my heart when I googled the guy who played No-Jik and found out that he was accused for sexual assault. I mean ik It's not related I still just wanted to share lol. Also Kim Woo-Bin actually dealing with cancer in real life was my last straw. Please I Couldn't take anymore of it. I can't wait for his comeback. And I really pray and hope that he's doing well.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Plot: Kim Woo Bin has his main role and did an amazing job, Suzy acted natural, and that was the point of her character.
Story:It's not something "WOOOW", it's simple. Anyway it was great, has a sweet relationship, I love the way they made the flashbacks. But the drama was so depressive. Every episode is so sad and made me cry all the time ;__;
Many people hated the end, and I absolutely understand why, but I have to say, I liked it. It was so real and pure. Yes, I cried all the time with a smile just because the story is so beautiful xD It doesn't matter how many times you watch it...you will always cry.
Give it a try.
I hope Kim Woo Bin oppa gets better and returns to making amazing dramas like this (but happy ones) :(
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Yes, it was melodramatic, but what did you expect ? You can't have THAT plot and not include sad scenes. But it wasn't as melodramatic as the other reviews say. I too thought it'd be 20 episodes of "oh no I'm gonna die" but not at all. The plotline is so much more than just the main character having an uncurable illness, and we barely even see the illness's effects during most of the drama.
Besides, it looked genuine (thanks not only to the script but also to Woobin's acting), and I think it's the most important when knowing the difference between a bad melodrama and a good, sad drama.
Both the beginning and the end were genuine and amazingly done. The middle did look a little messy, but how can you miss out on that drama just because it's "too melodramatic" ? I strongly recommend it, and I think it could suit anyone's taste since it's not just romance or tear-drop-material.
Story :
The first part of the story is satisfying - we don't have to wait to learn about the illness since it's known since the very first scenes. There's nothing in the first episodes that frustrated me. The flashbacks are well done and there's no unnecessary flashback-related cliffhangers but there's still more to learn after every episode. The beginning is really interesting and well paced. I couldn't believe the episodes weren't 20 minutes long. The fact that they focused on the documentary and on the main characters wwas something I appreciated.
But then comes the second part, and it got a little bit boring, with many, many, many scenes of the Choi family doing their boring stuff. It doesn't help the plot either, it's just like it's a side plot that will eventually come in handy. I skipped some of those scenes to be honest and it never affected my comprehension of the main plotline. Talking about the main plotline - the main character gets hard to understand and relate to. It's frustrating because everything could have been so much easier with just a little communication but no !! He has to do dumb stuff !! Anyway, during the middle part, we barely even hear about the illness and the documentary (which were the plotlines I craved for). It transforms into a thriller. I liked it, but I probably won't remember half of what happened in those side-plots in a week.
And then, the final part.. cleared up all the built up frustration of the middle part. No more useless scenes, back to talking about the documentary a little bit, back to talking about the illness and actually being ill. I finally could get attached to some of the side characters. I cried a lot tbh.
Overall, I'd say that the story gets a little... distracted ??? in the middle, but it helps to show how determined the main character is to clean up his mess before leaving. It is frustrating, and the relationship between the two main characters is a little weird, somehow obsessive, but interesting. I liked it. I also like that we knew how it was going to end, from start to finish, it was clear, and helped guide us through the more prone-to-confusion side-plotlines
Cast :
Suzy was okay, the actress who played Joonyoung's mom was great and overall most of the characters related to No Eul and Joon Young were good actors, But!! There are two actors I really didn't appreciate : im joo hwan (choi ji tae) and Im ju Eun (Yoon Jung Eun). Choi Jitae was hard to play since he's already a blank character, but I really didn't feel like he suited the role at all.
I'm still giving a great note because Kim Woobin's acting was amazing. His sleeping face is more expressive than the whole Choi family (except Haru). He's a great actor, what more can I say.
Music :
The songs weren't outstanding but the ambiant sounds were great at building up tension subtly. It wasn't too "in-your-face" but I feel like they did a great job on the sounds, more than on the songs (not saying the songs weren't good - they were - but I think I'll mostly remember the small ambiant details rather than the main OSTs)
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Hay doramas que saben como romperte el corazon.
Si estoy triste este es uno de los doramas que vuelvo a ver. La producción, la historia, la música y los actores saben como sacarte un buen numero de lagrimas. Cada vez que lo miro y avanzo en capítulos espero un final diferente pero no sucede... Kim Woo Bin supero mis expectativas en este drama, dio todo de si y ame y amo lo bien que actuó. Im Joo Hwan en mi villano predilecto pero en este drama me mostró otra versión de el que me hizo querer verle en mas dramas en un papel romántico. Y mi adorada Suzy, no tengo ni que decir de ella. Espero verlos actuar en mas dramas.Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The male main character made many decisions that were not understandable at first and later you were able to understand it a bit... but not totally.
It was very heart- and nerve-wrecking.
But one thing I have to admit: it was that good and exciting that I finished this drama in just 4 days! (Still in pre-Christmas-exam-period, so it is fast!!)
All actors did a great job! I was so impressed that they acted with emotions that seemed so pure and realistic.
The story line was very exciting and I cried soooo many times, which I normally don't, cause I know that it's not real... I always had to "wake myself up" that I'm back to reality after watching it.
Heartbreaking, but awesome Drama!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Story was pretty tearjerking, what would someone do when diagnosed with terminal disease? Worry about fulfilling his life, or worry about who he is leaving behind...?
I know many people didn't like kim woo bin's character but you have to imagine how far he's pushed into a corner, his eyes tell hundreds of words just by looking into the camera. The others were each perfect in their roles too.
The soundtracks were perfectly timed to the scenes and forces the manliest man to cry like a little girl. Every time I hear Little Braver I remember so many scenes.
This is a MUST watch if you're into melodrama, get ready to cry your eyeballs out.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
And how many times was the FL going to stand outside ML's house sulking and hoping to be let in like a lost puppy?
This drama wasn't for me.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Sad But Beautiful Story
I have read many of the reviews of what many thought about this show, and whether certain situations were unnecessary or not. But for me, I couldn't care less about how the story should or had unfolded. After completing this drama all I have to say is it conveyed quite a powerful and meaningful message to me.It provokes the idea of what one would do with the limited time they are given. The story begins with our main lead playing out a role for an action film in which he is scripted to die in the end but faced with his own reality of having a terminal illness he exclaims "I don't want to die like this". Of course, given his situation, this drama then ends with the death of our actual main lead in the final episode. There were a lot of complicated and unforeseen turns of events that played throughout the series but ignoring all that, we were left with the raw context that was being directed toward the viewers. What would we do if were told our time was coming to an end? In a way, the show demonstrates to us the scenario of our two main leads and how they chose to deal with their situations. Whether the choices they made were right or wrong, it became clear what each character was lacking was the acknowledgement and appreciation of each other's presence within their lives. Our male lead's mother filled with her own desire to be acknowledged by his father didn't cherish her son enough before coming to realise it, and our female lead didn't appreciate her father's effort to make a living for them enough until his sudden death. Our male lead chose to ignore his feelings or conscious and continued to live a somewhat reckless but abundeful life and therefore only focused on his success and ignoring the suffering of others who weren't of his concern. All it took to change the fates of those around him was the notice of his limited time.
Not everyone's life is a drama and therefore many forget that we face life and death on the daily basis. Each time we cross the street without the use of traffic lights, each time we stand underneath or near construction site on levels above ground level, each time we use our phones while driving, or drink our sorrows away. From the moment we awake to the moment we sleep we are on the verge of death, yet many of us live unfulfilling lifes that only continue to drain the very life within us like a terminal illness. This was what I believed this drama was conveying to its veiwers as I went from episode to episode. It was this final message that help me veiw this story as a Sad but beautiful journey of life.
If you don't believe me, don't take my word for it and try the drama yourself. Unlike me you may come to hate it or you may find it boring and too dramatic but you'll never know till you give it a try just like everything else in life.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
