Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Another Live Action Fail
I finally have the time to write a review for the live action iteration of the universally loved anime/manga series, Yu Yu Hakusho. It's no secret that I wasn't as overly pleased with this as I hoped I would be. But I kinda suspected I would hate it the moment I saw the trailer and found out it's only going to be 5 episodes. Yu Yu Hakusho was one of my favorite anime series back in the day so I expected so much from this.
Sadly, this live action series as a whole is mediocre at best. Not great. Not awful. Just mid. There are things I loved and things I hated with a passion. First, the positive. The action choreography is simply flawless, the long shots are fluidly executed, the creativity in how the fighters use their environment to gain advantage is pure unadulterated fun. Unfortunately, that's all it has going for it. The story is a mishmash of several story arcs that should've and could've been adapted properly if they had chosen to go with the first two arcs in the first season. The manga series is relatively short to begin with, they could've written a far better adaptation if they actually used the source material. But maybe it's a one-and-done type of series so they figured they should use elements from the other story arcs that made the series so beloved.
The characters are lackluster save for Kuwabara, who is actually my least favorite in the anime. He's the only one who goes through real character development and was the most interesting character in the whole series hands down! Yusuke is meh. Just a meathead punk I couldn't care less about. Hiei is an emo kid walking around with a humongous chip on his shoulder but you don't know why because he doesn't have a character arc unlike in the original. Genkai they just did dirty. Was I supposed to care about her? Really? I couldn't tell. Botan was not cute but annoying and the actress they chose overacted so much. Although I don't mind Keita Machida as Koenma, I wish they had opted to use his baby form instead because having a grown man walk around with a pacifier in his mouth is just gross. Toguro was not even the slightest bit intimidating and the CGI on his final form was laughable. He resembled a bread dough that has been kneaded for far too long and shaped to look like an anatomically incorrect human torso. But the biggest disappointment was Kurama. My god, why oh why did they have to cast Jun Shison for the role?! He looks like a cosplayer with a bad wig! He just doesn't look good with hair color that's not black. He is undeniably Asian-looking that whenever he dyes his hair, he looks like he's going to an anime convention wearing a cheap synthetic wig he ordered online. And the guy can't act his way out of a paper bag. There are plenty others who would've been more suitable for the part. Apart from his action stunts, which were solid by the way, he was not the Kurama I know. Faaaaaaar from it!
Maybe I'm just biased because I have fond memories of the original and I couldn't help but keep comparing the two. I wanted so badly to like this. In fact, I was looking forward to watching it. But the first episode already felt off to me. Everything seemed so cheesy from the way Yusuke acted to the dialogue and the overall vibe of the series. The CGI was hit or miss. Sometimes it appeared superbly executed, sometimes it was terribly cartoonish. If I were to rate this series, I would give it a 5.5 out of 10 for the action choreography, stunt work, and Kuwabara. It has very low rewatchability for me. I would probably just watch clips of some of the fight scenes, most especially the Yusuke versus Goki one. But that's about it.
Sadly, this live action series as a whole is mediocre at best. Not great. Not awful. Just mid. There are things I loved and things I hated with a passion. First, the positive. The action choreography is simply flawless, the long shots are fluidly executed, the creativity in how the fighters use their environment to gain advantage is pure unadulterated fun. Unfortunately, that's all it has going for it. The story is a mishmash of several story arcs that should've and could've been adapted properly if they had chosen to go with the first two arcs in the first season. The manga series is relatively short to begin with, they could've written a far better adaptation if they actually used the source material. But maybe it's a one-and-done type of series so they figured they should use elements from the other story arcs that made the series so beloved.
The characters are lackluster save for Kuwabara, who is actually my least favorite in the anime. He's the only one who goes through real character development and was the most interesting character in the whole series hands down! Yusuke is meh. Just a meathead punk I couldn't care less about. Hiei is an emo kid walking around with a humongous chip on his shoulder but you don't know why because he doesn't have a character arc unlike in the original. Genkai they just did dirty. Was I supposed to care about her? Really? I couldn't tell. Botan was not cute but annoying and the actress they chose overacted so much. Although I don't mind Keita Machida as Koenma, I wish they had opted to use his baby form instead because having a grown man walk around with a pacifier in his mouth is just gross. Toguro was not even the slightest bit intimidating and the CGI on his final form was laughable. He resembled a bread dough that has been kneaded for far too long and shaped to look like an anatomically incorrect human torso. But the biggest disappointment was Kurama. My god, why oh why did they have to cast Jun Shison for the role?! He looks like a cosplayer with a bad wig! He just doesn't look good with hair color that's not black. He is undeniably Asian-looking that whenever he dyes his hair, he looks like he's going to an anime convention wearing a cheap synthetic wig he ordered online. And the guy can't act his way out of a paper bag. There are plenty others who would've been more suitable for the part. Apart from his action stunts, which were solid by the way, he was not the Kurama I know. Faaaaaaar from it!
Maybe I'm just biased because I have fond memories of the original and I couldn't help but keep comparing the two. I wanted so badly to like this. In fact, I was looking forward to watching it. But the first episode already felt off to me. Everything seemed so cheesy from the way Yusuke acted to the dialogue and the overall vibe of the series. The CGI was hit or miss. Sometimes it appeared superbly executed, sometimes it was terribly cartoonish. If I were to rate this series, I would give it a 5.5 out of 10 for the action choreography, stunt work, and Kuwabara. It has very low rewatchability for me. I would probably just watch clips of some of the fight scenes, most especially the Yusuke versus Goki one. But that's about it.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?